Bob Thompson, Historian

MARINER, REAL ESTATE SALESMAN, COAD YARD OPERATOR, JOURNALIST, AND SONOMA COUNTY’S FIRST HISTORIAN

Original cover of the Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, 1877 (Sonoma County Library)

It’s New Year’s Day 1875, and you have settled in Sonoma County. Twenty-five years have passed since the county was established; one hundred years since the area’s first significant Spanish contact. Like others, you made the hazardous journey west looking for prosperity and happiness. Instead, you’ve faced years of uncertainty. You’ve seen agricultural booms and busts, cataclysmic fires and floods, property battles over Mexican land grants, and ugly political divisions during the Civil War.

Now, a national recession is driving down crop and livestock prices. Farmers are losing their land. Capitalists are creating “bonanza farms” using steam-powered machinery. Unemployment is on the rise, generating hostilities toward low-paid Chinese immigrants.

What you could use is some assurance, an acknowledgement that despite all the turmoil, your sacrifices, hard work, and persistence have been worthwhile. On January 2, 1875, it arrives; a special edition of the Sonoma Democrat commemorating Sonoma County’s 25th anniversary hits the newsstands.[1]

Front page of Sonoma Democrat newspaper, January 2, 1875 (Newspapers.com)

The county’s first extensive history, the edition sidesteps its troubled times, focusing instead on the successful efforts of hardworking settlers like yourself in creating such a prosperous region.

Its author, Robert A. Thompson, Jr., or “Bob” as he is known, seems an unlikely choice for first county historian. A former San Francisco coal dealer, he has been working at the Sonoma Democrat for only two years. The style and format of his history, however, point to something of his intentions, as they mimic the text found in popular county atlases across the country.

Robert A. Thompson (Honoria Tuomey, History of Sonoma County, 1926, p. 207)

A phenomenon launched in the Midwest soon after the Civil War, the county atlas is a large, 15-by-18-inch, leather-bound book designed for parlor table display. Available only by pre-order from door-to-door canvassers, it sells for about $15 a copy ($460 in today’s currency). Each book contains more than 100 pages of hand-colored maps of a county’s landholdings and towns, as well as biographies commissioned by prominent settlers, and illustrations of farms, businesses, and buildings also commissioned by their owners.  An uplifting county history ties all the pieces together.[2]

Illustration of county atlas artist creating commissioned illustration of farm (courtesy of Bates Harrington’s “How ‘Tis Done”)

Bob began writing his history in 1874, the same year the two creators of the county atlas phenomenon, Louis H. Evarts and Thomas H. Thompson, announced plans to bring their atlas phenomenon to California.[3] A year later, Thompson (no relation to Bob) launched a new atlas publishing company in San Francisco with Albert A. West. They called the company “Thompson & West.”[4]

Albert A. West & Thomas H. Thompson (Sacramento Bee, July 18, 1958, newspapers.com)

The two began by developing atlases for Santa Clara, Solano, and Alameda counties. In 1876, they decided to add Sonoma County to the mix, which was when they met Bob.[5]

The Thompson Brothers

A member of a prominent Virginia family—both his father and grandfather had served in Congress—Bob sailed for California as a mariner in 1852, after graduating from the University of Virginia.[6] His uncle, Philip Roote Thompson, Jr.— one of Sonoma County’s first judges—had already settled in Petaluma.[7]  

The following year, Bob’s father, former Virginian congressman Robert A. Thompson, Sr., was appointed to the three-man California Land Commission. Charged with sorting out the legal claims to the state’s 813 Mexican land grants, the commission helped lay the ground for a new gold rush of land sharks and speculators in the state.[8] Looking to cash in, Bob’s uncle, Judge Philip Thompson, opened a real estate office in Petaluma and hired Bob as a sales agent.[9]

In 1860, Bob married Elizabeth West, a fellow Virginian, and settled in San Francisco operating a coal yard.[10] Twelve years later, in 1872, he sold the coal business and moved his family to Santa Rosa to work as an editor for his younger brother, Thomas Larkin Thompson, owner of the Sonoma Democrat newspaper.[11]

“Tom,” as he was known, came to California in 1855 at age 17. A printing apprentice, he worked a couple months at the San Francisco Herald before moving to Petaluma to launch the town’s first newspaper, the Petaluma Weekly Journal and Sonoma County Advertiser. After six months, he sold that paper and returned to the Herald before taking a job at the San Francisco Post Office. In 1860, he purchased the Sonoma Democrat and moved to Santa Rosa.[12]

Thomas L. Thompson (public domain)

Raised in a slave-owning family, the Thompsons held white supremacist and Anglocentric views which they unabashedly expressed in the Sonoma Democrat.[13] During the Civil War, the newspaper served as the voice of Southern settlers in Sonoma County, arguing for the legality of slavery under States Rights, publishing Confederate propaganda that teetered on the brink of treason, and dismissing Union victories as fake news.[14]

Soon after the war, Tom sold the Sonoma Democrat and moved to Vallejo, where he briefly published two newspapers. He returned to Santa Rosa in 1871, repurchased the Sonoma Democrat, and hired his brother Bob along with a second brother, Frank, a printer, as co-editors.[15]

Illustration of the Sonoma Democrat office in Santa Rosa featured in the Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, 1877

All three brothers harbored political ambitions. First to realize them was Frank, who was appointed California’s state printer in 1875.[16] Bob meanwhile set his sights on becoming Sonoma County clerk. Writing the county’s first history that year was likely his means of burnishing his credentials.[17]

In 1876, atlas publishers Thomas Thompson and Albert West came calling at the Sonoma Democrat, seeking an endorsement of their forthcoming Sonoma County book. Upon learning the newspaper had already published a county history Bob produced the year before—in their format no less—they agreed to let Bob write an expanded version of his history for inclusion in their atlas. They also gave him rights to publish the history independently.[18]

Title page of the Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, 1877

In August 1877, The Historical Atlas of Sonoma County was delivered to its subscribers.[19] The book featured 12 colored maps; 15 town and village plats; 120 commissioned illustrations of farms, businesses, and buildings; five commissioned biographies and portraits of prominent settlers; and Bob’s enhanced history.

Sonoma County map & illustrations of Petaluma Argus and Sonoma Democrat, Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, 1877
Commissioned illustration of Nicholas Carriger’s ranch in Sonoma, Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, 1877

A few weeks before its release, Bob announced his candidacy for county clerk. He also published his atlas history in a separate pamphlet entitled A Historical and Descriptive Sketch of Sonoma County, making it available in bookstores for$1 ($30 in today’s currency). Campaigning on his laurels as the county’s first historian, Bob was elected to his first of three consecutive terms as Sonoma County clerk.[20]

Title page of A Historical and Descriptive Sketch of Sonoma County, 1877

Thompson’s History of Sonoma County

In following the county atlas format for his history, Bob provided a straightforward description of Sonoma County’s origins, climate, geography, topography, agriculture, and industries, drawing upon county records and newspaper clippings. He made some minor errors—Mariano Vallejo’s Rancho Petaluma, for example, consisted of 66,000 acres, not the 75,000 cited in his history—but he provided a quantitative account of the county’s agricultural and industrial output over its first 25 years.[21]

To fill in gaps in the official records, Bob relied upon interviews with early settlers. Some of those accounts, as Sonoma County historian Jeff Elliott noted, had the veracity of stories shared over beers in a local saloon.[22]

That’s because, as cleverly demonstrated in Akira Kurosawa’s famous 1950 film Rashomon, the human memory can be a fickle storyteller. Wildly selective, muddled, and malleable, it feeds on feelings and experiences to construct meaning. If rigorous, evidence-based history can be said to be secular in its willingness to incorporate new findings and perspectives, memory commits to a sacred set of fixed stories that speak to heritage and identity, even if they are not entirely factual.[23]

A telling example is Bob’s depiction of the 1854 transfer of the county seat from Sonoma to Santa Rosa. He described the transfer of country records by wagon as taking place under “dire threats of injunction and violence from the Sonoma people.” That dramatic account was later disputed by the teamster who actually conveyed the records.[24]

Other oral histories gathered by Bob would cloud the historical record for decades to come. Petaluma’s founding in 1852 is a case in point. Bob identified the town’s founder simply as “a man named Keller.” He also mistakenly identified the town’s first postmaster as an early merchant named W.D. Kent, when in fact it was the mysterious Keller’s 21-year-old son, Garret Valentine Keller.[25]

1857 illustration of Petaluma (courtesy of the Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

The postmaster error was subsequently corrected by J.P. Munro-Fraser in his 1880 History of Sonoma County, but that correction led later historians to mistakenly assume Petaluma’s founder was “G.W. Keller.”[26] It wasn’t until 2021 that the city’s true founder was determined to be Garret’s father, George Horine Keller, who went on to cofound the city of Leavenworth, Kansas.[27]

Bob also failed to mention that Keller founded Petaluma illegally on part of a Mexican land grant he didn’t own. While Bob did recount the legal battle over the land grant’s proper ownership, he left out the fact that the city was in legal limbo for 20 years until 1874, when the U.S. Supreme Court finally resolved the matter.[28]

Likewise, Bob steered clear of other contentious conflicts over land grants, including the armed showdown in 1859 between the Settlers’ League and the owner of the Bodega Rancho. Instead, he falsely asserted that land grant claims “were settled without much dispute or delay, and the sub-divided lands were purchased by industrious and enterprising farmers.”[29]

Omissions like those are common in Bob’s history. Like a modern-day visitors center, he focused on celebrating the progress of early settlers, social organizations, businesses, and cultural traditions. In doing so, he promoted a false inevitability to Sonoma County’s creation.

That wasn’t unusual for the county atlas genre itself, which blatantly embraced the doctrine of Manifest Destiny, America’s divine duty to conquer, settle, and prosper in the promised land of the west.[30] Hubert Howe Bancroft, who was assembling a comprehensive history of California at the time, was a major proponent. (His namesake, the Bancroft Library at UC Berkeley, recently issued a report criticizing his work as “riddled with contradictions, tensions, and ambiguities.”) [31]

In adhering to Manifest Destiny in the scope and context of his history, Bob buried or minimized the conflicts, failures, and injustices of the county’s formation. That included turning a blind eye to the exploitation and devastation of the indigenous population when the region was under Spanish and Mexican rule. For an account of that period, Bob appears to have relied upon the writings of Mariano Vallejo, who, at Bancroft’s request, had recently written his own five-volume history.[32]

Mariano Vallejo with elderly Pomo woman, 1878 (Sonoma County Library)

Vallejo largely positioned the decimation of the region’s native peoples as inevitable and beyond human control, thereby absolving him and others of any moral responsibility for their acts of violence, massacre, and malfeasance. That included his role in the lethal smallpox epidemic of 1838. While ample means of inoculation were available, he distributed them primarily to his fellow Californios, but not to the natives working in servitude at his Petaluma Adobe.[33]

It is not surprising that of the five commissioned biographies featured in the 1877 Historical Atlas of Sonoma County—presumably written by Bob—one is a glowing tribute to Vallejo, praised for having led a “more honorable” life than any man could claim.[34]

That biography captures in a nutshell the calculated distortion of Bob’s historical account. Despite his useful compilation of historical records, his history’s origin as part of a publication targeted to the financial interests, concerns, and ideological values of its paid subscribers—many of them prominent settlers and capitalists able to afford such a costly book—compromises its integrity as little more than propagandizing history.

It is best read as a reminder of how power, ambition, and money control the narrative of what is to be remembered, and what is left behind to be forgotten.

Bob Thompson Postscript

As for Bob, after serving three terms as Sonoma County Clerk, he returned in 1882 to editing the Sonoma Democrat following his brother Tom’s election as California’s Secretary of State. In 1884, Bob published a history of Santa Rosa before accepting an appointment as San Francisco’s port appraiser. He returned to the Democrat in 1893 when Tom was designated U.S. minister to Brazil. Four years later, the Thompson brothers sold the newspaper after Tom returned from Brazil following a nervous breakdown. He committed suicide a few months later.[35]

Bob made an unsuccessful run for Secretary of State in 1898, then returned to journalism, spending his final years as general manager of Out West magazine in San Francisco. At the time of his death in 1903, he was working on a history of California.[36]

Out West Magazine (courtesy of Arizona Memory Project)

A version of this story appeared in two parts in the 2026 Summer and Fall editions of the Sonoma Historian.

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “The County of Sonoma: A Brief Historical Sketch,” Sonoma Democrat, January 2, 1875.

[2] Walter A. Friedman, Birth of a Salesman: The Transformation of Selling in America (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004), pps. 37-39; Cheryl Lyon-Jenness, p. 169; “Board of Supervisors,” Sonoma Democrat, March 11, 1876; “Board of Supervisors,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877. Note on pricing: In 1876, Sonoma County’s Board of Supervisors approved the purchase of 15 copies of the Sonoma County atlas for $225, or $15 each. They approved an additional acquisition of one copy in 1877 for $15.

[3] “The Coming Atlas of California,” San Francisco Chronicle, November 18, 1874; Cheryl Lyon-Jenness, “Picturing Progress: Assessing the Nineteenth-Century Atlas-Map Bonanza,” Michigan Historical Review, Vol. 30, No. 2, Fall 2004), pps. 171-172; Note: In 1874, Evarts and Thompson planned to create a state atlas of California, based on a state atlas they had just completed for Minnesota.

[4] David F. Myrick, Introduction to the 1958 Reprinted Edition of Thompson & West’s History of Nevada, 1881 (Howell-North, Berkeley, CA, 1958), p. h; Cheryl Lyon-Jenness, p. 168.

[5] “County News,” Vallejo Chronicle, September 29, 1876; “Proposed New Maps,” Oakland Tribune, January 25, 1877; “Nine Men Have Had Part in Building P.D. in the Last 71 Yrs.,” Press Democrat, October 28, 1928.

[6] U.S. Census, California, 1852, p. 699: Bob is listed as living in San Francisco as a mariner.

[7] Died,” Sonoma Democrat, November 5, 1864; The Historical Atlas of Sonoma County (Oakland, CA: Thompson & Co., 1877), p. 19; “Pen is Laid Aside,” Press Democrat, August 5, 1903; Sonoma County Deeds, Liber B, Book K, Page 176, February 15, 1853; Note: In 1853, Philip R. Thompson purchased from Mariano Vallejo 160 acres  for his ranch at the southwest corner of Adobe and Corona roads, where Bethel School (later known as Waugh School) was located.

[8] “The Late Judge Thompson,” Sonoma Democrat, September 9, 1876; David Hornbeck, “The Patenting of California’s Private Land Claims, 1851-1885,” Geographical Review, Vol. 69, No. 4 (October., 1979), pgs. 438, 443; Hornbeck, pps. 435-438; Donald J. Pisani, “Squatter Law in California, 1850-1858,” Western Historical Quarterly, Autumn, 1994, Vol. 25, No. 3, pps. 286, 291-292.

[9] Ad for Philip R. Thompson, Petaluma Journal, September 22, 1855; Ad for Thompson & Shattuck, Petaluma Journal, November 28, 1856; “List of Letters,” Petaluma Journal, October 2, 1857: letter waiting at Petaluma post office for R. Thompson; “List of Delinquent Taxes,” Sonoma Democrat, November 28, 1858: Robt. Thompson listed as agent in sale of 160 acres in Petaluma valley to Andrew Glassell, a relative, for $1,280.

[10] “Married,” Sonoma Democrat, May 3, 1860; “Births,” Sonoma County Journal, June 21, 1861: In San Francisco, wife of R.A. Thompson gave birth to a son, Andrew; Ad for R.A. Thompson & Co. Coal Yard, San Francisco Examiner, November 29, 1865; U.S. Census, California,1870, p. M593: Robert A. Thompson, coal dealer, living in San Francisco’s 10th Ward with wife Elizabeth and four children, including Andrew, age 9.

[11] Ad for R.A. Thompson, Dealer in Coal and Wood, San Francisco Examiner, August 15, 1871: this the final ad for Thompson’s coal yard to appear in any San Francisco newspapers.

[12] Newspaper Change,” Nevada Democrat, May 9, 1860; “Thomas L. Thompson,” Petaluma Courier, February 1, 1898.

[13] Jeff Elliott, Santa Rosa History, Santarosahistory.com: “A Far Away Outpost of Dixie,” June 29, 2018, “Lessons on Who Is Much Lesser Than You,” August 7, 2020, “A Short Truce in the (Un)Civil War,” September 18, 2017; Thompson family as slaveowners: 1850 U.S. Census Kanawha, Virginia: P.R. Thompson, Jr: 53 years old; farmer; also living in the property: Sarah (43), Philip (19), Susan (17), George (13) Lucy (14), Eliza (9), Lillias (7), Ellen (5), George (3) and seven slaves without names assigned to them.

[14] Gaye LeBaron, “Sonoma County Marks 165 years of Local Newspapers,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, October 22, 2021;  Jeff Elliott, “A Far Away Outpost of Dixie,” June 29, 2018, “A Short Truce in the (Un)civil War,”  September 18, 2017, Santa Rosa History, Santarosahistory.com.

[15] “Changed Hands,” Petaluma Argus, July 8, 1871; Masthead, Sonoma Democrat, June 15, 1872: first listing of Thomas L. Thompson, publisher and proprietor; R.A. Thompson and F.P. Thompson, editors; “Thompson Was a Pioneering Publisher,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, August 3, 1975. Note: Tom Thompson mistakenly believed Vallejo would become the North Bay’s main shipping port once the California Pacific Railroad laid its tracks from Vallejo to Santa Rosa. Instead, a competing railway, the San Francisco & Northern Pacific Railroad, established the main commercial route from the Petaluma River near Lakeville to Santa Rosa. In Vallejo, Thompson operated the Solano Democrat and the Vallejo Daily Independent; Jeff Elliott, “Santa Rosa’s 1871 Railroad Riots,” Santa Rosa History, December 6, 2108, http://santarosahistory.com/wordpress/2018/12/santa-rosas-1871-railroad-riots/

[16] Pacific Coast Items,” Marysville Daily Appeal, December 11, 1875.

[17] “Democrats,” Petaluma Argus, June 25, 1875.

[18]  “Nailed to the Counter,” Sonoma Democrat, June 19, 1877; “A Kindly Recommendation,” Sonoma Democrat, June 19, 1877; “Sonoma County,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877; “Now Ready,” Petaluma Courier, October 4, 1877.

[19] “Thompson’s Sonoma Atlas,” Petaluma Courier, August 16, 1877; Historical Atlas of Sonoma County (Oakland, CA: Thompson & Co., 1877), p. 3; Note: the Sonoma County atlas was published under the imprint “Thos. H. Thompson & Co.,” presumably because Thompson’s partner, Albert West, was not involved with writing the history section; “Sonoma County,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877.

[20] “Democratic Ticket,” Petaluma Argus, July 20, 1877; “Sonoma County,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877; “Board of Supervisors,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877; Historical and Descriptive Sketch of Sonoma County (Philadelphia: L.H. Everts, 1877). Note: L.H. Everts was Thomas H. Thompson’s former atlas partner in Illinois, implying that T.H. Thompson may have arranged its publication; “Sonoma County,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877; “Board of Supervisors,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1877.

[21] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, p. 14; Ogden Hoffman, Reports of Land Cases Determined in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California (Numa Hubert, San Francisco, 1862), Appendix, p. 35. https://digitalcommons.csumb.edu/hornbeck_usa_3_d/16/

[22] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, p. 3; Jeff Elliott, “The Fable of the Stolen Courthouse,”  August 31, 2017, Santa Rosa History, Santarosahistory.com.

[23] Betsy Brinson, “Crossing Cultures: An Interview with Alessandro Portelli,” Oral History Review, Vol. 28, No. 1 (Winter/Spring 2001), p. 108; David Blight, “History and ‘Memory,” Commonplace, the Journal of Early American Life, Issue 2.3, April 2002.

[24] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, pps. 20½ -21; Tom Gregory, History of Sonoma County (Los Angeles: Historic Record Company, 1911), pps. 149-150.

[25] “Post Offices in California,” Sacramento Daily Union, November 15, 1852; Postmasters 1832-1971, Archives. Gov. https://www.archives.gov/research/post-offices/postmasters-1832-1971.html; Note: it appears Petaluma’s first post office was located in George Horine Keller’s general store on Washington Street beside the Petaluma River.

[26] J.P. Munro-Fraser, History of Sonoma County (Allen, Bowen & Co., 1880) pps. 259-260; Tom Gregory, History of Sonoma County (Los Angeles, Historic Record Company,1911) p. 177: identifies Petaluma’s founder as “G.W. Keller”; Ed Mannion, Rear-View Mirror column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, April 2, 1960: lists “G.W. Keller” as Petaluma’s founder.

[27] “The True Story of Petaluma’s Founder,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 11, 2021; “Territorial Legislature of 1857-58,” Kansas Historical Society Collection, Vol. 10, 1907-1908, p. 211.

[28] “The True Story of Petaluma’s Founder,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 11, 2021; “Letter from Petaluma,” Daily Alta California, April 16, 1855.

[29] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, p. 13; “Settler Excitement,” “The Bodega Difficulty,” Sonoma County Journal, June 3, 1859; Jeff Elliott, “The Man Who Stole Bodega Bay,” Santa Rosa History blog, May 17, 2014, http://santarosahistory.com/wordpress/2014/05/the-man-who-stole-bodega-bay/

[30] Anders Stephenson, Manifest Destiny: American Expansion and the Empire of Right (NY: Hill & Wang, 1995).

[31]  Bancroft Library Reckoning Committee Final Report, UC Berkeley Chancellor’s office, June 2025, https://chancellor.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/blrc_public_report_june_2025.pdf.

[32] Rose Marie Beebe and Robert M. Senkewicz, Mariano Guadalupe Vallejo: Life in Spanish, Mexican, and American California (University of Oklahoma Press, 2025), p. xiv. Note: Vallejo wrote his five-volume history of Alta California, Recuerdos: Historical and Personal Remembrances Relating to Alta California, at the request of California historian Hubert H. Bancroft, who subsequently rejected publishing them.

[33] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, p. 29; Sherbourne F. Cook, “Smallpox in Spanish and Mexican California (1770-1854),” Bulletin of the History of Medicine, v.7, (February 1939), pps. 153-191; Benjamin Madley, American Genocide (Yale University Press, 2017), p. 185; Beebe and Senkewicz, p. 60.

[34] Historical Atlas of Sonoma County, p. 94.

[35] Robert A. Thompson, Central Sonoma: A Brief Description of the Township and Town of Santa Rosa (San Francisco, Wm H. Hinton & Company, 1884); “R.A. Thompson Resigns,” San Francisco Chronicle, January 24, 1891; “What is Said,” Sonoma Democrat, April 29, 1893; “Thomas L. Thompson,” Petaluma Courier, February 1, 1898; “R.A. Thompson,” Petaluma Courier, August 4, 1903; “Newspaper Change,” Healdsburg Tribune, September 30, 1897.

[36] “Curry Elected Secretary of State,” San Francisco Chronicle,” November 16, 1898; “Out West,” San Francisco Call Bulletin, February 16, 1902; “R.A. Thompson,” Petaluma Courier, August 4, 1903.

Who Built this Building? The Daly & Sroufe Grocery

Thrifty Hippy Thrift Store, 218 Petlauma Boulevard North (photo John Sheehy)

In May 1856, and Irish immigrant named James Daly opened a grocery on Upper Main Street just beyond Washington Street, one door above the offices of the Sonoma County Journal office.[1]

He was joined in the business in July 1857 by John Sroufe, a native of Ohio who had just moved to town from El Dorado County, where he and his wife settled after coming to California for the gold rush in 1850.[2] The grocery was renamed Daly & Sroufe. That same month they moved into a new, fireproof store at was then numbered 102 Main Street, across from the Plaza (most likely today 226 Petaluma Boulevard North).[3]

In August 1862, Daly & Sroufe moved their grocery into a new brick building adjacent to their old store at 88-90 Main Street (today 218 Petaluma Boulevard North). They added iron fronts to the building.[4] In 1865, Sroufe bought out Daly, and in 1868 changed the name of the grocery to J. Sroufe & Co.[5]

In 1870, Sroufe sold his grocery to B. Reinhardt and D. Hildburgh, who renamed it Hildburgh & Reinhardt, and moved to San Francisco, where he became a wealthy liquor wholesaler. In 1873, Hildburgh bought out Reinhardt, and renamed the grocery Hildburgh & Bros.[6]

Interior of J.L. Winans & Son Grocery, circa 1900 (Sonoma County Library)

In 1881, Hildburgh & Bros. declared they were insolvent. Their grocery was taken over by James L. Winans and Marcus Goshen. In 1887, Winans bought out Goshen, changing the name of the grocery to J.L Winans & Son.[7]

1895 photo of a firemen’s pumping contest with J.L. Winan & Co.’s Grocery at 218 Main Street (Sonoma County Library)

After Winans died in 1910, his widow sold the grocery to Herman Peters, a native of Penngrove, who combined it with the Grand Saloon he operated in the adjacent building. He brought his brother Henry in as a partner, and the two combined the saloon and grocery as Peters & Peters.[8]

Peters & Peters Grocery, 218 Main Street, 1910s (Sonoma County Library)
Illustration of Herman and Henry Peters at their grocery, 1923 (Petaluma Courier)

In 1922, Herman  bought out his brother Henry. He continued to operated Peters & Peters on his own until his retirement in 1947.[9]

Peters & Peters Grocery, 218 Main Street, beside Forman Hardware Company, 1947 (Sonoma County Library)

The grocery was briefly taken over by George’s Food Center, before being purchased in 1949 by the Auto Parts Supply Company, ending its days as a grocery.[10]

The Auto Parts Supply Company sold the building in 1960. Since then, the building has been occupied by a number different businesses over the years, including antique stores such as Dead People’s Stuff and French Hen Antiques, and currently, the Thrifty Hippy Thrift Store.[11]

Interior of building as French Hen Antiques, 2011-2016 (public domain)
Today’s Thrifty Hippy Thrift Store, 218 Petaluma Boulevard North (public domain)

Thanks to Terry Park of the Petaluma Historical Library & Museum for his research assistance.

For more on the grocery merchant who built the building, John Sroufe, check out:

******

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “Death of James Daly,” Petaluma Courier, June 27, 1888; First ad for James Daly grocery, Sonoma County Journal, May 17, 1856.

[2] “Was Petaluma’s First Merchant,” Petaluma Courier, July 18, 1904; “List of Letters: John Sroufe,” Sonoma County Journal, October 10, 1856; Findagrave.com: Mollie Sroufe Merrill (1853 to 1925) and E. Sroufe Loosley (1856 to 1940). Sroufe’s first daughter Mollie was born 1853 in El Dorado County, and his second, Susan, was born in Petaluma in 1856.

[3]  Ad for “New Firm—Daly & Sroufe,” Sonoma County Journal, July 17, 1857; Ad for Daly & Sroufe, 102 Main Street, Sonoma County Journal, May 6, 1859.

[4] “Dissolution Notice, Sonoma County Journal, August 29, 1862.

[5] “Grocery Store,” Petaluma Argus, January 19, 1865; “Change of Business,” Petaluma Journal & Argus, August 25, 1868: Sroufe’s brother David joins him at J. Sroufe & Co.; “Our County Fair,” Petaluma Argus, October 7, 1868.

[6] First ad for Reinhardt & Hildburgh, Petaluma Argus, May, 1870; “Dissolution Notice,” Petaluma Argus, May 14, 1873.

[7] “Insolvent notice,” Petaluma Courier, October 12, 1881; “New Firm,” Petaluma Argus, November 11, 1881; “Dissolution of Copartnership,” Petaluma Argus, July 2, 1887.

[8] “Are Retiring From Business,” Petaluma Argus, January 28, 1910; Peters & Peters purchase, Petaluma Courier, February 15, 1910.

[9] “Herman Peters Buys Interest of Brother,” Petaluma Courier, April 19, 1922; “Peters & Peters Store to Close; Owner Will Retire,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, March 15, 1947.

[10] “Henry Reynaud Buys Peters & Peters Building on Main Street,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, March 17, 1947: Ad for George’s Food Center, 218 Main Street, formerly Peters & Peters, Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 10, 1949; “Auto Parts Firm in New Location,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 21, 1949.

[11] “Auto Parts to Move to 4th Street,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, October 20, 1960: Auto Parts Supply Company build a new store at 32 4th Street; First listing of Thrifty Hippy Thrift Store, Petaluma Argus-Courier, October 4, 2012; https://patch.com/california/petaluma/thrifty-hippy-is-one-hip-thrift-store

Skip Sommer: History with verve, a wink, and a smile

Skip Sommer (photo Crissy Pascual, Petlauma Argus-Courier)

In October, 2026, Skip Sommer announced he had written his last “Petaluma’s Past” column for the Argus-Courier, marking the end of an era.

Skip, who turned 95 a few weeks later, began writing his local history column in 1987, a decade after making some local history of his own. A former stage actor and IBM salesman turned historic theme developer, in 1976 Skip readapted a shuttered grain mill into an arcade of specialty shops called The Great Petaluma Mill, kicking off a restoration boom that revived Petaluma’s historic downtown.

Skip Sommer beginning renovation of the Great Petaluma Mill, 1976 (photo Morrie Camhi)

Skip’s business card back then read: “Skip Sommer, historical restoration with verve.” He brought that same verve to chronicling historical events.

Skip Sommer’s business card, 1978 (courtesy of Skip Sommer)

“It was in 1987,” Skip recalled, “that the publisher of the Petaluma Post, David Bennett, took me for a beer at McNear’s Saloon and asked me to join his newspaper staff as their history columnist. I resisted until the third beer. Now, 40 years later, after some 600 columns in the Post and, for the past decade, the Argus-Courier, I’m calling it quits.”[1]

Skip Sommer’s column in the Petaluma Post, “Stories from the Past,” ran from 1987 to 2015; his column in the Petaluma Argus-Courier, “Petaluma’s Past,” ran from 2016 to 2026

While his columns chronicled a wide range of national and international historical events, Skip always brought them back to what was happening in Petaluma at the time. His columns — a mix of political and social events, news tidbits, and wry observations — read like a letter from an old friend with a knowing wink and smile.

Skip Sommer’s business card as a student at Michigan State University, 1949 (courtesy of Gregg Fautley collection)

It was his asides of snide humor — a skill Skip mastered in his acting days on stage — that brought verve to his columns. In tribute to Skip, I’ve selected a few of my favorites:

  • In 1909, canned beer had not yet been invented, but marijuana, heroin and morphine were all available over the county. In fact, one Petaluma pharmacy advertised: “Heroin clears the complexion, gives buoyancy to the mind and regulates the bowels.” Oh boy![2]  
  • In 1911, a California ordinance was instituted against “the obnoxious dance, the Rag.” In Petaluma, it was a misdemeanor to dance the Rag. The editor of the Petaluma Courier wrote that, “if a couple was to begin to indulge in this vile manner, the music should stop to halt the evil.” Wowie. Good thing he never saw the Twist.[3]
  • In 1912, Petaluma’s Raymond Brothers Clothing carried Warner’s “rust-proof shaping corset for the growing girl.” (Really, rust-proof?) And if one became ill in Petaluma, one could always go to “H.L. Lorenzen, physician and surgeon, specializing in electrical and vibratory treatment.” Oh boy![4]
Longtime Petaluma Argus-Courier columnist Bill Soberanes presenting Skip Sommer with Petaluma good Egg Award, 1985 (Petaluma Argus-Courier)
  • In 1852, sanitation and hygiene were non-existent in Petaluma. There were no sewers, penicillin or even Band-Aids. A simple cut or burn could have been lethal. Popular medical treatments included pouring whiskey on wounds or splashing on a poultice of wet cow dung. Petaluma’s drinking water was brought in by barrel from local springs. You could buy a bath in a tin tub upstairs over the saloon. The choices included “cold water, warm water, first water or second water.” Having a saloon girl wash your back cost extra. Zowie![5]
  • In 1889, there were 64 telephones in Petaluma. The editor of the Petaluma Argus commented, “Even Nicasio will now be connected to the wicked world, and some are in favor of extending the telephone to Olema!” Be still my heart![6]
  • Lest today’s homeowners lust after Petaluma’s elegant Victorians, keep in mind they were not so comfy back in the day. While some indoor plumbing was to be had in 1890, the good old outhouse was the standard, making for a mighty cold run out the back door on a wintry night. And those icy wood seats? Oh well.[7]
Skip Sommer with members of the Volpi’s Historian Society (photo Scott Hess)
  • In 1903, Petaluma was having its troubles. A strike was threatening to permanently close the silk mill, an actual snowfall contributed to massive flooding, and houses of ill-repute, frequented by “the worst of depraved men,” were declared by the Petaluma Argus to be “a nuisance and disgrace to our wholesome community!” But on the plus side, our first bowling alleys were popping up, several beer gardens were adding something called ping-pong, and Dr. John Kergan announced he would be at the Washington Hotel for two days, providing cures for “catarrh, bowel troubles, liver and kidney ills, piles and obscure diseases.” All this at the hotel?[8]
  • Prohibition ended on March 16, 1933, when the U.S. Senate voted to allow beer to be manufactured and imbibed if its alcohol content was reduced to 3.2 percent from the 5 percent it had been prior to Prohibition. Our Argus-Courier boasted the following headline: “Beer Will Be Available for Breakfast Here.” For breakfast? Really?[9]
  • Prior to 1933, our local habit had been to flush sewage right into the Petaluma River. Our Chamber of Commerce actually bragged that “Petaluma sewers were flushed clean by the tides twice a day!” A real sanitary system, Petaluma’s mayor proclaimed, “will convert the river into one of the best saltwater fishing streams in the State.” Ah, rocket science.[10]
Skip Sommer and partner Joanne Tepper (photo courtesy Tom Corbett)
  • In May of 1945, there were two subjects that dominated the news in Petaluma. One, of course, was World War II. The other was a growing debate over California permitting manufacturers of oleomargarine to color their product yellow. Local dairymen were up in arms. An editorial in the Argus-Courier stated, “The color does something to butter that does not happen to oleo!” Do tell.[11]
  • While war raged around the world in the summer of 1944, in the Valley of the Moon a fight was blossoming over the Sun-O-Ma Nudist Colony. The Press Democrat, “getting down to the bare facts regarding those nude nomads flitting around the Sonoma hills,” reported that they were about to “learn the naked truth of poison oak and mosquitos.” But the poignant question was how, with gasoline rationed during wartime, did the nudists acquire enough gas to get to the camp? To find out, the Office of Price Administration staged a raid on the camp. “The agents who drew the lucky assignment,” the newspaper reported, “were a couple of hardy boys who came out still blushing.” One young lass was “standing unabashed with her curves,” exclaiming “Heavens, my husband doesn’t know I’ve been using the car to come up here!” The Press Democrat’s headline read: “200 Cavorting Nudes Facing Loss of Gas!” (The devil made me include that quote).[12]
Local historians, Skip Sommer and John Sheehy, in front of Petaluma’s town clock (John Sheehy collection)

 “History is always a mixed bag,” Skip noted, summing up his 40 years as a columnist. “It’s been great fun exploring the intriguing backstory of our exceptional small town.”


A version of this story appeared in the Petaluma Argus-Courier, November 6, 2026.

******

FOOTNOTES:

[1] Adapted with Skip from his Petaluma’s Past column, January 12, 2017.

[2] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, January 14, 2016.

[3] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, June 30, 2016.

[4] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, October 6, 2016.

[5] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, May 19, 2016.

[6] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 7, 2016.

[7] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, December 14, 2017.

[8] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 9, 2023.

[9] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 22, 2018.

[10] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, June 13, 2019.

[11] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, May 5, 2016.

[12] Petaluma’s Past column, Petaluma Argus-Courier, April 18, 2019.

[13] Petaluma’s Past columns, Petaluma Argus-Courier, January 12, 2017, and March 7, 2019.

Who Built This House? The Murphy Building

The Murphy Building at 695-697 Petlauma Boulevard North (photo John Sheehy)

The Murphy Building at the southwest corner of Petaluma Boulevard North and West Street was built in 1916 by Dennis Murphy as a neighborhood grocery and residence.[1]

Murphy emigrated to California from Ireland in 1875, settling in San Francisco, where he worked as a grocer. In 1912, at the age of 53, he moved to Petaluma, purchasing the East Petaluma Grocery and Delicatessen on the southeast corner of East Washington and Vallejo streets (across from today’s Whole Foods).[2]

Dennis and Mary Murphy with their daughters Cecelia and Constance, outside the East Petaluma Grocery, 630 East Washington Street, 1912 (Sonoma County Library)

The East Petaluma Grocery was three years old, having been built and operated by A. Seligman and his wife. Seligman also purchased 10 acres along East Washington Street between Vallejo and Edith streets, which he subdivided into residential lots for sale. After his wife became critically ill in 1911, Seligman sold the grocery to Murphy, and the couple moved back to San Francisco.[3]

Murphy added a second floor to the building for his family to live in, a common tradition of merchants living above their stores.[4] His first wife, Minnie, with whom he had seven children, had died in 1897 at the age of 33. In 1909, he married Mary Carter of Sebastopol. They couple had two young daughters, who resided with them above the grocery, his children from his first marriage apparently all grown by that time. [5]

In 1916, Murphy purchased an empty lot at the corner of West Street and Petaluma Boulevard North (then North Main Street), and constructed a new Murphy’s Grocery on it, built in a style that largely mimicked that of the East Petaluma Grocery, with living quarters for his family upstairs.[6]

Ad for Murphy’s Grocery, Petaluma Courier, December 21, 1917

Murphy operated the new grocery for only three years before his death in 1919. His wife Mary maintained ownership of the building, living upstairs and leasing out the downstairs grocery to five different merchants during the 1920s, who apparently had a hard time making it work.[7] It doesn’t appear the grocery was operating during years of the Great Depression years.

Mary Murphy lived in the building until her death in 1943. Her daughter Connie, who inherited the building, sold it to local sign maker Lew Barber, and joined Women’s Naval Reserve, or WAVES. Barber set up his store on the first floor, and his family moved into the residence upstairs.[8]

Barber Sign Company, 695- 697 Main Street, 1948 (photo courtesy of Paul Barber)

In 1947, Lew was joined in the business by his brother Warren. Recently discharged from the U.S. Navy, Warren was trained in making neon signs. Lew installed an Army-surplus Quonset hut in the backyard for Warren to use as his neon sign shop.[9]

Barber Sign Company’s neon sign shop in the Quonset hut, early 1950s (photo courtesy of Paul Barber)

In 1956, Barber moved his company to a new location in town, selling the buildings to The Pride of Petaluma Brooder Stove Company, which had been operating their store and plant two doors away since 1924. They leased it out to L&L Furniture & Appliances until 1964, when it returned to being a neighborhood grocery called Ben’s Trading Post. Ben and then Bev Miller operated the store until 1970.[10]

In the years since, the Murphy Building has seen a series of businesses pass through, including as the Tropical Fish Store in the 1970s, a tanning salon, and most recently, the Daily Care Massage Parlor.

Daily Care Massage, 867 Petaluma Boulevard North (public domain)

Thanks to historian Katherine Rinehart for her research assistance. More info on the Barber Sign Co. can be found at her website, https://kjrinehart.com/, and in her book The Petaluma Vintage Signs Guidebook.

FOOTNOTES:

[1] Petaluma Argus, June 13, 1916.

[2] “D. Murphy is Summoned,” Petaluma Courier, October 11, 1919.

[3] “George P. McNear Sells 10-acre Tract,” Petaluma Argus, June 12, 1908; Ad for city lots for sale by Seligman, Petaluma Courier, August 13, 1909; “Building a Store,” Petaluma Courier, October 26, 1909; “Will Open New Store Wednesday,” Petaluma Argus, November 29, 1909; “A Fine New Store,” Petaluma Courier, December 14, 1909; To Submit to Operation,” Petaluma Courier, April 23, 1910; “Local Notes,” Petaluma Argus, December 22, 1911.

[4] “Grocery Store Sold Yesterday,” Petaluma Argus, January 30, 1912.

[5] “Deaths,” San Francisco Chronicle, June 14, 1897; “More Marriage Licenses Granted,” Petaluma Argus, March 18, 1909; https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/151017093/dennis-murphy. Note: two of Murphy’s children from his first marriage had died by the time he moved to Petaluma.

[6] Mr. Murphy building new home, Petaluma Argus, June 13, 1916; First ad for D. Murphy Grocery at Main and West streets, Petaluma Argus, June 27, 1917.

[7] “Filed Will for Probate,” Petaluma Courier, October 18, 1919; “Deeded Property to Widow,” Petaluma Courier, October 19, 1919; “Bought Murphy Grocery,” Petaluma Courier, March 17, 1920; “J. O’Rourke Opens Murphy Store,” Petaluma Argus, May 5, 1920; “Disposed of Grocery Store,” Petaluma Courier, February 18, 1921; “Bought Lock Grocery,” Petaluma Courier, October 5, 1921; “Temple Grocery is Sold,” Petaluma Argus, September 11, 1923; Ad of Grocery for rent at 695 Main, Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 18, 1929.

[8] “Death Takes Mrs. Mary Murphy,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 11, 1943; “Mary C. Murphy left Estate to Daughter,”  Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 22, 1943; “Constance Murphy Thrilled with WAVES,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 20, 1944; “Personal Items,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 14, 1944.

[9] First ad for Barber Neon, Petaluma Argus-Courier, July 28, 1947; Written note from Carol Cook, daughter of Lew Barber: “My father, Lew Barber’s, first sign shop was in this building and we lived upstairs. When his brother, Warren Barber, got out of the Navy in the 1940’s, my Dad bought the Quonset Hut and had it erected for Warren when he came home after learning neon skills. Later, they moved their business to several different spots in Petaluma and also had a shop in Vallejo. Two of Warren’s sons also worked in their business.”

[10] Ad for new Petaluma Brooder Stove Co., Petaluma Courier, March 15, 1924;“Brooder Firm Buys Main St. Property,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 1, 1956; First ad for L&L Furniture & Appliances, Petaluma Argus-Courier, July 23, 1956; First ad for Ben’s Trading Post, 697 Petaluma Boulevard North, Petaluma Argus-Courier, June 19, 1964; “So They Tell Me” column: Tropical Fish Store, Petaluma Argus Courier, December 2, 1970.

John Sroufe: A Rags to Riches Story

In 1862, Petaluma merchant John Sroufe and his partner James Daly built themselves a new grocery in a building currently occupied by the Thrifty Hippy Thrift Store at 218 Petaluma Boulevard North. After 14 years in the grocery trade in Petaluma, Sroufe went on to become one of the wealthiest whiskey merchants and mining investors in the American West.

Born in Kentucky and raised in Ohio, Sroufe crossed the plains to California via wagon train with his wife in 1850. The couple spent a few struggling years in El Dorado County, where their first daughter was born, before settling in Petaluma in 1856. [1]

Ad for Daly & Sroufe Grocery at 102 Main Street, 1861 (Sonoma County Journal)

The next year, Sroufe partnered with an Irishman named James Daly in opening the Daly & Sroufe Grocery on Petaluma’s Upper Main Street across from Hill Plaza Park, at what is today 226 Petaluma Boulevard North. In 1862, they built a new brick building next door—at what is today 218 Petaluma Boulevard North—and relocated their grocery there. [1a]

In the 1910s, the Daly & Sroufe Grocery building at 218 Main Street was occupied by Peters & Peters Grocery (Sonoma County Library)

Sroufe became actively engaged in the Petaluma business and political communities, serving as a city trustee (city councilman) from 1863 to 1865.[2] He and his wife lived with their three daughters at 237 Keller Street (the Sroufe house was replaced in 1908 with the current house on the site by W.F Farrell).[3]

In 1865, Sroufe bought out Daly, changing the name of grocery to J. Sroufe & Co.[4] Two years later, he purchased an interest in a wholesale producer dealer with H.L. Dodge in San Francisco, which became Dodge & Sroufe. In 1870, he decided to move to San Francisco. Selling his grocery to Reinhardt & Hildburgh, he bought out his partner Dodger in the wholesale produce business, and, with a new partner named L.R. Sweeney, renamed the business Sroufe, Sweeney & Co. He also invested in extracting mercury from his Excelsior Quicksilver Mining Company north of Healdsburg.[5]

As for Sroufe, Sweeney & Co. in the Petaluma Argus, September 16, 1871

In 1875, Sroufe changed gears again. Selling his interest in the produce wholesale company, he partnered with an Irish entrepreneur named Hugh McCrum to purchase J.M. Goewey & Co., a liquor wholesaler on Front Street. Renamed Sroufe & McCrum, the company specialized in imported liquors and Kentucky whiskey. A colorful character who made a small fortune mining silver in the Comstock Lode, McCrum roamed the West as the company’s salesman, while Sroufe managed affairs at the home office.[6]

Ad for Sroufe & McCrum, Tucson Citizen, July 7, 1880

With their business flourishing, Sroufe & McCrum moved into larger quarters at 208-210 Market Street in 1880 .[7] They also started looking for new business opportunities. 

The Sroufe & McCrum Liquor Wholesale office, 208-210 Market Street, San Francisco, 1880 (Golden Gate NRA, Park Archives)

In 1883, Adolph Sutro, the soon-to-be mayor of San Francisco, bought the Cliff House, a city icon perched upon rock above the Pacific Ocean. Built in 1863 as an exclusive resort for the wealthy, the Cliff House had fallen on hard times and was losing money. After investing in an extensive renovation, Sutro leased out the resort’s main attraction—its restaurant—to Sroufe and McCrum.[8] 

A photo taken in 1883 of the Cliff House in it first incarnation (1863 to 1894), before burning down in 1894 (OpenSFHistory.com)

To Sutro’s displeasure, they attracted a clientele of drinkers and gamblers, giving the Cliff House a scandalous reputation and resulting in him terminating their lease within two years. He instructing their successor, James M. Wilkins, to “clear out the riffraff,” and restore the restaurant to a family-friendly atmosphere.[9]

Wilkins operated the restaurant for the next 17 years, during which time the Cliff House burnt down in 1894 and was rebuilt by Sutro in a more elaborate rendition. During those years, Wilkins often turned to Sroufe for loans of liquor and cash to stay afloat. Finally, in 1903, Sroufe called in the debts which had grown to $38,000 ($1.4 million in today’s currency). As Wilkins was unable to pay, Sroufe was left holding the bag.[10]

Front page article on Sroufe calling in debt from James M. Wilkins at the Cliff House restaurant (San Francisco Examiner, November 20, 1903)

In the mid-1880s, Sroufe and McCrum turned their attention to Arizona, which McCrum regularly visited while peddling liquor to saloons. Investing in ranches and commercial properties, they also became partners for two years in the Bird Cage Theater, a notorious saloon in Tombstone, Arizona.[11]

Bird Cage Theater (TombstoneBird Cage.com)

Known for rowdy behavior, the theater’s walls were riddled with gunshot holes. The 12 balcony boxes inside doubled as a bordello between performances. The basement meanwhile hosted one of the longest poker games in history. With a buy-in of a thousand dollars ($35,000 in today’s currency), the game was played continuously for eight years, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. It drew such notables as George Hearst, Diamond Jim Brady, Adolphus Busch, Doc Holliday, Bat Masterson, and Wyatt Earp.[12]

A more lucrative side business for Sroufe and McCrum in Arizona was mining gold and silver.[13] Their most lucrative investment was in the Silver Belt mine, which by 1888 had produced $300,000 of silver ($10 million in today’s currency), with expectations of millions more to come.[14]

In 1892, McCrum, retired from the liquor wholesale business—which Sroufe renamed J. Sroufe & Co.—to devote himself to expanding the partners’ mining investments in Arizona. In 1893, they joined with L.C. Hughes, governor of the Arizona Territory, as investors in the lucrative Silver Cave mine.[15]

John Sroufe & Co. whiskey label (Western Whiskey Gazette)

Over his years in San Francisco, Sroufe maintained strong ties in Petaluma, continuing to serve as a stockholder in the Petaluma’s First National Bank, and making regular trips to town to visit with old friends.[16]

He died of pneumonia in 1904 at the age of 77, leaving an estate worth $500,000 ($20 million in today’s currency).[17]


FOOTNOTES:

[1] “Death of James Daly,” Petaluma Courier, June 27, 1888.

[1a] Ad for “New Firm—Daly & Sroufe,” Sonoma County Journal, July 17, 1857; Ad for Daly & Sroufe at 102 Main Street, Sonoma County Journal, May 6, 1859; “Dissolution Notice, Sonoma County Journal, August 29, 1862; Our Mechanical Enterprises,” Sonoma County Journal, October 24, 1862.

[2] “City Officers of Petaluma,” Petaluma Courier, April 12, 1877.

[3] “The Death of Mrs. J. Merrill,” Petaluma Argus, October 31, 1925: Sroufe daughter cites the family home address as 237 Keller Street; Note: in 1908, the house at 237 Keller Street, presumably Sroufe’s,  was owned by William F. Farrell, who sold it to Charles Offutt, who then moved it to an empty lot at 516 Kentucky Street, next door to the former Revere House, which he had moved the same year to 512-514 Kentucky Street. In its place at 237 Keller Street, Farrell hired Brainerd Jones to design the house that currently stands there. Meanwhile, the house Offutt moved to 516 Kentucky Street was apparently torn down for the Petaluma Grocery parking lot in 1941 (“Purchased Farrell House,” Petaluma Courier, July 21, 1908; Splendid Improvement on Kentucky Street,” Petaluma Argus, March 17, 1916; “Bought Fine New Home,” Petaluma Argus, September 21, 1920; “House Warming at the Kynoch Home,” Petaluma Argus, November 10, 1920).

[4] “Grocery Store,” Petaluma Argus, January 19, 1865; “Our County Fair,” Petaluma Argus, October 7, 1868: first ad under J. Sroufe & Co.

[5] “Attention, Dairymen,” Petaluma Argus, November 28, 1867; Dissolution of Partnership,” Petaluma Argus, April 15, 1869; Ad for Reinhardt & Hildburgh, Petaluma Argus, May, 1870: they bought Sroufe’s grocery; Ad for Dodge & Sroufe, Petaluma Argus, July 2, 1870; Ad for Sroufe, Sweeney & Co., Petaluma Argus, November 26, 1870; “A Trip to the Mines,” Petaluma Argus, February 26, 1875.

[6] “New Firm,” Petaluma Argus, May 21, 1875; Ad for Sroufe & McCrum,” Petaluma Argus, August 27, 1875; Ad for Sroufe & McCrum, San Francisco Chronicle, February 5, 1880; “Chaparral Quartz,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 9, 1893; Hugh McCrum, the West’s Peripatetic Whiskey ‘Capitalist,’” Those Pre-Pro Whiskey Men!, pre-prowhiskeymen.blogspot.com.

“Hugh McCrum, the West’s Peripatetic Whiskey ‘Capitalist,’” Those Pre-Pro Whiskey Men!, pre-prowhiskeymen.blogspot.com.

[7] Ad for Sroufe & McCrum, San Francisco Chronicle, February 5, 1880.

[8] “Hugh McCrum, the West’s Peripatetic Whiskey ‘Capitalist,’” Those Pre-Pro Whiskey Men!, pre-prowhiskeymen.blogspot.com.

[9] “The Long & Peculiar History of the Cliff House in San Francisco,” TheVintageNews.com, https://www.thevintagenews.com/2016/12/29/the-long-peculiar-history-of-the-cliff-house-in-san-francisco;

[10] “Attaches the Cliff House,” San Francisco Chronicle, November 20, 1903; “Cliff House Will Go to Receiver Today,” San Francisco Examiner, November 20, 1903; “Wilkins Reopened Cliff House Yesterday,” San Francisco Chronicle, November 22, 1903.

[11] Michael Paul Mihaljevich, The Bird Cage Theater: The Curtain Rises on Tombstone, Arizona’s National Treasure (University of North Texas Press, 2024).

[12] “History of the Bird Cage Theater,” tombstonebirdcage.com.

[13] “Chaparral Quartz,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 9, 1893.

[14] “Personals,” Viriginia City Daily Territorial Enterprise, November 1, 1883; “Arizona: Prosperous Condition of the Silver Belt Mine,” San Francisco Chronicle, May 31, 1888;

[15] Legal Notice, San Francisco Examiner, January 4, 1892; “Chaparral Quartz,” San Francisco Chronicle, September 9, 1893; “$32,000: The Amount of Another Bond on a valuable Mining Property at Dos Cabezas,” Tombstone Epitaph, October 11, 1893.

[16] Ad for First National Gold Bank, Petaluma Argus, October 1, 1875; Sroufe visits cited in the Petaluma Courier: September 9, 1885; August 29, 1888; September 4, 1889; June 17, 1891; April 20, 1895; March 16, 1898; December 24, 1900; Sroufe visits cited in the Petaluma Argus: May 1, 1886; September 3, 1887.

[17] “Was Petaluma’s First Merchant,” Petaluma Courier, July 18, 1904; “Leaves Entire Estate Unconditionally to His Wife,” San Francisco Call, July 20, 1904.

Who Built This House? The Legendary Revere House

The Revere House, 512 Kentucky Street, 1959 (Sonoma County Library)

In 1962, a fire broke out on Kentucky Street between Kent and Galland streets, destroying one of the oldest landmark buildings in Petaluma.

Built in 1861 as a hotel called the What Cheer House—later renamed the Revere House—it originally sat at the southeast corner of Oak Street and Petaluma Boulevard North. In 1907, part of the building was moved to 512 Kentucky Street, where it became a private residence.

The hotel was built by George W. Cofer, who came to Sonoma County in 1852, having crossed the plains from Missouri in a wagon train. He initially settled on a farm west of Petaluma and married Nancy Ann Peters. In 1861, the couple moved into private quarters in their newly constructed What Cheer House.[1]

Stagecoach outside the What Cheer House, Main and Oak Streets, 1860s (Sonoma County Library)

Three stories high, the hotel had 50 rooms, a dining hall and bar, and an adjacent livery stable. For many years it was the largest hotel in town, offering a commanding view of Petaluma Valley and the Sonoma Mountain Range. The nightly room rate was 25 cents a night ($10 in today’s currency).[2]

Cofer borrowed the name from the popular What Cheer House in San Francisco. That city’s largest hotel, it initially opened 1852, admitting only male guests and banning liquor on the premises.[3] The hotel’s name came from an old English expression—“What cheer, friend?”— a friendly salutation commonly used during the Gold Rush.[4]

What Cheer House on Sacramento Street in San Francisco, 1850s (Library of Congress)

Cofer’s guests were primarily teamsters, farmers, and drovers bringing grains, produce, and livestock into town. The hotel’s livery stable featured a scale for weighing hay and grain. Across the street sat Petaluma’s early flour mills. A free shuttle transported guests to and from the steamboat ferry landing on the river. The hotel also served as a stagecoach depot for passengers venturing north to Santa Rosa or Sebastopol.[5]

In 1865, Cofer sold the hotel and departed for Honolulu. He later took his wife and children to Peru, where they allegedly became the first Americans to cross the Andes. The Cofers ultimately settled on a farm near Red Bluff. [6]

Ad for the Stockdale House, 1866 (Petlauma Weekly Argus)

The hotel’s new owner, Hugh Stockdale, came to Sonoma County from Pennsylvania in the early 1850s. Owner of a dry goods store in Bloomfield, he was an avid horse breeder, and helped to organize the first county fair held in Petaluma in 1867.[7]

Stockdale changed the name of the What Cheer House to the Stockdale House, and refurnished it to appeal to not only to farmers and teamsters but also to their families.[9] He lived with his own family in the private quarters Cofer created at the hotel. After two years, Stockdale leased the hotel to Reuben L. Gardner, one of California’s legendary hotel keepers, but continued to reside there with his family .[10]

Ad for Reuben L. Gardner’s Revere House, 1867 (Petlauma Weekly Argus)

A native of Rhode Island, Gardner had operated a series of hotels in California and Nevada, beginning with Sacramento’s Crescent City Hotel in 1850. He renamed Stockdale’s hotel The Revere House, most likely after Boston’s famous hotel of the same name. Within a couple years, Gardner moved on to a new hotel venture.[11]

The Stockdale family continued to reside at the hotel for the next 40 years, leasing its operation to a series of proprietors. Stockdale died there in 1890, followed by his wife Carrie 12 years later. In 1906, Stockdale’s children moved out and sold the building, but not the lot, to Charley Offutt, a local dairyman. [12]  

Offutt first arrived in Petaluma in 1853 as a one-year-old infant traveling with his parents on a wagon train from Missouri.[13] His parents established 1,000-acre dairy ranch that stretched from Chileno Valley to Tomales Bay. Offutt took it over after their passing. In 1906, he decided to retire from dairy ranching and moved into town with his wife.[14]

Offutt’s main reason for buying the hotel building was to use its hand-hewn lumber in constructing a new house on a lot he purchased a block away. The lot extended from Petaluma Boulevard North to Kentucky Street. Subdividing the lot, Offutt used the lumber from the hotel’s first floor to build a Craftsman-style home for his family at 509 Petaluma Boulevard North (adjacent today to the former parking of North Bay Kitchen & Bath).[15]

Offutt House, built 1907 with lumber from the Revere House, 509 Petaluma Boulevard North (public domain)

He moved the top two stories of the Revere House to Kentucky Street, where he converted them into a single private residence he rented out. For brief periods, Offutt’s daughter Jennie, a graduate of the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, lived there with her husband Arlington W. Stephenson, a music professor. Touring performers during the Vaudeville era, the couple eventually moved to San Francisco.[16]

Following Offutt’s death in 1935, Jennie Offutt Stephenson moved back into the old Revere House, apparently to be close to her elderly mother. Having recently separated from her husband, she began running a series of local night clubs—the Silver Dollar Club, the Rainbow Inn, and the Depot Hotel in Valley Ford (today’s Dinucci’s Restaurant)—with nightly jazz bands and dancing.[17]

Former Revere House as private residence downstairs and upstairs apartments, 512 Kentucky Street, 1953 (Sonoma County Library)

During World War II, Stephenson converted the top floor of the old Revere House into four rental apartments.[18] On the evening of February 6, 1962, a smoldering cigarette left in one of the rented rooms set off a fire that severely damaged the old building.[19]

Fire at the Revere House, 1962 (Sonoma County Library)
Aftermath of the fire at the Revere House (Sonoma County Library)

Stephenson tore down the remains of building and in its place constructed the four-unit apartment complex that resides on the site today. The only remanent of the landmark Revere House is the lumber in the old Offutt house at 509 Petaluma Boulevard North.

Apartment Complex, 512-518 Kentucky Street, 2026 (public domain)

A version of this story appeared in the Petaluma Argus-Courier, October 9, 2026

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “Married,” Sonoma County Journal, April 10, 1857; Ad for the What Cheer House, Petaluma Argus, September 20, 1861; “Death of G.W. Cofer,” Daily Red Bluff News, August 6, 1895.

[2] Ad for the What Cheer House, Petaluma Argus, September 20, 1861; “Jottings,” Petaluma Courier, January 29, 1879: best hotel view in town.

[3] “Library of Congress Images Show S.F. As It Was Before 1870,” SF Gate.com, July 20, 2020.

[4] “The What Cheer House,” Stagenine.com, https://www.stagenine.com/pages/the-what-cheer-house

[5] Ad for What Cheer House, Petaluma Argus, September 20, 1861; Ad for Revere House, Petaluma Argus, April 4, 1867.

[6] For Sale ad for What Cheer House, Petaluma Argus, June 30, 1864; Ad for Stockdale House, Petaluma Argus, July 20, 1865; Ad for Stockdale House listing Stockdale as proprietor, Petaluma Argus, November 9, 1865; “Passengers,” Daily Alta California, March 25, 1865; “Passengers,” Daily Alta California, March 25, 1865.

[7] Ad for Miller & Stockdale Dry Goods Store, Sonoma County Journal, June 1, 1860; “County Fair, Petaluma Argus, April 11, 1867; “Dead,” Petaluma Courier, November 12, 1890.

[9] Ad for Stockdale House, Petaluma Argus, November 16, 1865.

[10] “Good Change All Around,” Petaluma Argus, March 14, 1867; First ad for the Revere House, Petaluma Argus, March 21, 1867; “Death of R.L. Gardner,” Oakland Tribune, August 8, 1877.

[11] “The Revere House,” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revere_House.

[12] “Dead,” Petaluma Courier, November 12, 1890; “Death Calls Mrs. Stockdale,” Petaluma Argus, May 10, 1902; “Briefs,” Petaluma Courier, September 25, 1903: rooms still being rented at Revere House; “Briefs,” Petaluma Courier, June 4, 1906: Stockdale heirs move out of hotel.

[13] “Pioneer Ranch Owner, 83, Passes,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 28, 1935.

[14] “Pioneer Ranch Owner, 83, Passes,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 28, 1935; “Jennie Stephenson Dies in Petaluma,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, December 25, 1977.

[15] “Historical Unity Meets Next Week,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 23, 1959.

[16] “Life Ends for Mrs. Isable Farrel,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, April 9, 1945; Jennie Stephenson Dies in Petaluma,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, December 25, 1977.

[17] Jennie Stephenson Dies in Petaluma,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, December 25, 1977.

[18] “Silver Dollar Reopens August 29,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 24, 1936; “Rainbow Inn to Be reopened Saturday,” Santa Rosa Republican, June 24, 1937; “Valley Ford Hotel is Leased,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, March 4, 1938;  “Condition of Mrs. Offutt Critical,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, October 7, 1942; “Obituaries: Jennie B. Stephenson,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, December 24 1977.

[19] “Fire Ravages 97-year-old Revere House,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, February 12, 1962.

Petaluma’s Mythical Steamboat Rumble

Flat-bottomed scow schooner with hay on the Petaluma Creek (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

Petaluma was never just about chickens and cows. From day one, the city has been a transportation hub for goods and people. Which was why, legend has it, the town faced its first existential crisis in the summer of 1852.

Established the previous winter, Petaluma found itself unexpectedly confronted by a rival town calling itself Petaluma City. Located just a couple miles downstream on the Petaluma Creek—as the river was then known—the new town allegedly sought to replace Petaluma as Sonoma County’s main shipping port.[1]

Back then, the waterways were the highways. Petaluma Creek was sprinkled with the sails of flat-bottomed schooners hauling game meat, potatoes, and hay from Petaluma to San Francisco.But paddlewheel steamboats—the Bay Area’s main means of transportation—were nowhere to be seen. Robert A. Thompson, author of Sonoma County’s first written history, A Historical and Descriptive Sketch of Sonoma County, claimed tge deeper water vessels were afraid of running aground, given the creek was actually part tidal estuary that rose and fell twice a day with the ocean tides.[2]

Charles Minturn standing on the San Francisco wharf before his paddle steamboat the E. Corning, which he ran to Petaluma in the mid-1850s (Sonoma County Library)

According to Thompson, Petaluma City’s strategy for putting Petaluma out of existence turned on luring steamboats up the creek. In the fall of 1852, they persuaded the captain of a steamer called the Red Jacket to paddle his boat at high tide up the creek to their new landing.[3] As the remaining three miles of the creek to Petaluma were then a zigzagging maze of horseshoe bends— seemingly impossible for a steamboat to navigate—Petaluma was effectively left up the creek without a paddleboat.

1860 U.S. Coast Survey map shows oxbow bends in Petaluma Creek from Petaluma City, aka, New Town, at blue star, to Petaluma, red star (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

But Petalumans refused to concede defeat. They managed to convince the Red Jacket’s captain to pilot his boat through the serpentine bends to the Petaluma docks, thus putting an end to the steamboat rumble and ultimately to Petaluma City itself. [4]

Robert A. Thompson and his 1877 history of Sonoma County (photo Tuomey’s 1926 History of Sonoma County)

As origin stories go, Thompson’s reads like a tall tale told over drinks in a local saloon. Little of it holds water. While the creek undoubtedly posed a navigational challenge for steamboats in 1852, the reason they weren’t plying its waters was more likely because, aside from meat and potatoes, Petaluma had little to transport. But times were changing.

THE FOUNDING OF PETALUMA

In the summer of 1851, a 50-year-old gold miner from Missouri named George H. Keller rode into a camp along the Petaluma Creek. Set on a former Miwok trading village called Lekituit, the camp consisted of a few rustic cabins occupied by game hunters and a warehouse for storing potatoes, Sonoma County’s first boom crop.[5]

That fall, newspapers in San Francisco and Nevada City began running ads of farmland for sale in the Petaluma Valley.[6] Gold miners—only a fraction of whom made any money—began streaming into the camp, looking to stake their claim in California’s next gold rush: agriculture.[7] To accommodate them, Keller built a makeshift general store, hostel, and dining house beside the creek.[8]

Ad in the Daily Alta California newspaper, November 18, 1851

At the time, the Petaluma Valley, along with another 10 million acres in California, was subdivided into large Mexican land grants. Thanks to the 1848 Treaty of Guadalupe Hildago that ended the Mexican-American War, they remained in the hands of their Mexican owners. But not for long. By American legal standards, many of California’s land grants were sketchy or saddled with disputed claims. That included the 13,316-acre Rancho Arroyo de San Antonio the Petaluma camp sat upon, which was being claimed by two rival parties.[9]

To clean up the legal morass, in 1851 Congress appointed a three-man Land Commission to review California’s 813 land grants. The commission placed the legal burden of proving ownership upon the Mexican grant holders. Many of them, unable to pay the exorbitant legal fees, were forced to sell to American speculators, who then subdivided the land grants into farms and ranches for sale.[10]

Like everything during the Gold Rush, investing in real estate was a gamble. Buyers could either purchase a parcel in hopes the Land Commission would ultimately approve the speculator’s land grant claim—a process that could take many years—or they could illegally squat on the parcel in hopes the commission would reject the speculator’s claim. In such cases, the land grant would be placed in the public domain, allowing the squatter to make a homesteader’s claim to their parcel under the Preemption Act of 1841.[11]

Prone to taking gambles, many miners decided to roll the dice as squatters. Viewing themselves as entitled settlers, they banded together in legal associations, including at the Petaluma camp, where, in December 1851, a group formed The Settlers’ Association of the Rancho Arroyo de San Antonio.[12]

The association’s stated purpose was to monitor the Land Commission’s legal review process, but their real intention was to support George Keller in making a squatter’s claim to a 158-acre parcel upon which to establish the town of Petaluma. The group’s president, a 32-year-old miner from Pennsylvania named Major Henry P. Heintzelman, said it was a last resort after efforts to contact the rancho’s two rival owners were met with silence.[13]

In the fall of 1851, Keller hired a surveyor named John A. Brewster, who first came to California in 1846 as a cartographer with Captain John C. Frémont, to map out the town on 40 acres of his claim. He then began selling lots at his general store on Washington Street beside the creek.[14] His first recorded sale was on January 3, 1852, to David Flogdell, who purchased a lot at the foot of today’s Western Avenue, where he and Thomas Baylis built the Pioneer Hotel.[15]

John A. Brewster, surveyor (courtesy of the California State Lands Commission)

Keller’s sales were all filed by the Sonoma County recorder’s office, which apparently shared his skepticism that the Land Commission would ever determine a legal owner for the Rancho Arroyo de San Antonio. It helped that Brewster was the county recorder’s deputy clerk, and that Keller’s real estate attorney, a 46-year-old miner from Tennessee named Micajah G. Lewis, was appointed Petaluma’s first justice of the peace.[16]

To make sure buyers understood the risk involved, Keller promised in in his property deeds to defend buyers against lawful claims to their property, “except the confirmed titles of any Mexican Grant of the Government of the United States.”[17]

THE FOUNDING OF PETALUMA CITY

A few months after Keller began selling lots, his lawyer Lewis teamed up with Heintzelman, president of the local Settlers’ Association, to create Petaluma City. As a third partner, they brought in Colonel James B. Huie, 53-year-old businessman from Kentucky who operated an auction house in San Francisco.

Ad for San Francisco auction house of James B. Huie & Co., Daily Alta California newspaper, July 22, 1850

The three men then entered into a deal with Mariano G. Vallejo to develop Petaluma City on 600 acres of Vallejo’s 66,000-acre Petaluma Rancho that extended from the eastern bank of the Petaluma Creek to Sonoma.[18]   

Land grants around Petaluma and Petaluma City (“New Town”), including Vallejo’s Petaluma Rancho and the Rancho Arroyo de San Antonio, listed here as the Miranda Rancho (map Leander Ransom, Bancroft Library)

They centered the new town around Vallejo’s Landing on the creek at the end of Casa Grande Road.[19] Site of today’s Rocky Dog Park, Vallejo used the landing during his operation of the Petaluma Adobe to ship hides and tallow down the creek to San Francisco for export to Europe.[20]

Left, the original street grid of Petaluma City, 1852 (Sonoma County Deed Records); right, colored outline of the original street grid imposed on a current map of the area, with the original bends in the creek in blue (courtesy of Terry Park, Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

Cash-strapped after the Mexican-American War decimated his cattle empire, Vallejo took half interest in Petaluma City’s development—the odd numbered lots—apparently hoping he had found himself a new cash cow.[21]

Petaluma City (aka New Town) circled in red on Vallejo’s subdivisions of his Petaluma Rancho land grant, Rowe & Rowe map, 1850 (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

Within a month of filing the development with the county, Lewis sold his interest to Huie, retaining a handful of lots as a passive investor.[22] Huie and Heintzelman then opened a realty office at the southeast corner of Washington and Main streets, across from Keller’s store, and began selling lots to Petaluma City. Locals quickly nicknamed the development New Town.[23]

Contrary to Thompson’s account, it doesn’t appear Petaluma City’s developers were looking to usurp Petaluma as the creek’s head of navigation. There were no signs of bad blood between them and Keller, in fact, Lewis continued to serve as Keller’s real estate attorney.[24] It was more like a poker game with the Land Commission dealing the cards. Everyone knew Keller held a weak hand with his squatter’s claim, and Petaluma City’s developers were merely hedging their bets.[25]

Thompson’s story of the steamboat rumble is also dubious. He claims Huie convinced the captain of the Red Jacket (whom he misidentified as Captain Van Pelt) to pilot his boat up the creek to Petaluma City.[26] Huie—who later took credit for introducing steamboats to the creek—more likely convinced the Red Jacket’s owner, Thomas Hunt of the Union Line Company, that the route had sufficient freight and passenger demand to make it financially viable.[27]

Hunt purchased the Red Jacket specifically for Petaluma Creek. The steamer was previously owned by Charles Minturn—aka the “Ferryboat King”—who ran it between San Francisco and Oakland. In September 1852, Hunt bought the boat from Minturn and directed Captain L.B. Edwards to begin making runs from San Francisco to Petaluma three times a week. There were no scheduled stops at Petaluma City, which was still in early development. [28]  

The creek was, and remains, a challenging waterway. It descends from an altitude of 300 feet at its headwaters near Denman Flats to near sea level by the time it reaches Petaluma. There it converges with a tidal estuary extending 12 miles to the San Pablo Bay. Instead of flowing, the estuary rises and falls twice a day with the ocean tides. Sediment flowing down the freshwater portion of the creek—especially during rainy winters—settles as silt in the estuary. While that undoubtedly posed challenges to steamboats, they were manageable as long as their captains paddled the creek at high tide.[28a]

The Red Jacket’s run lasted only six weeks. After returning from a trip to Petaluma on November 2, 1852, it was severely damaged in a storm at the San Francisco wharf.[29] Steamboats would not return to the Petaluma Creek until the spring of 1853, when Huie and Heintzelman bought one of their own, the Soic, which they renamed the Reindeer. They began running the Reindeer three days a week from San Francisco to both Petaluma and Petaluma City, which had developed into a wharf, a couple of warehouses, and a handful of dwellings.[30]

Ad for Reindeer steamboat, Daily Alta California newspaper, March 4, 1854

In the fall of 1853, Minturn began running one of his steamboats, the E. Corning, between San Francisco and Petaluma three times a week.[31] It was his way of marking territory.

Charles Minturn standing before his steamboat the E. Corning, San Francisco, California, about 1852 (Sonoma County Library0

A few months later, he and other major steamboat operators formed the California Steam Navigation Company, assigning members monopolies to various waterways in order to impose higher fees by reducing competition. Minturn was awarded the steamboat monopoly on the Petaluma Creek.[32] He promptly added a second steamboat to the creek, the old Red Jacket, which he had repurchased, refitted, and renamed the Kate Hayes.[33]

THE DOWNTURN

Then California’s first recession hit, the result of overspeculation, a market glut of goods, and a real estate crash. Around that time, Sonoma County’s potato boom went bust, the victim of overproduction and soil depletion.[34] Petaluma, whose population had grown to more than 400 in 1854, began to stagnate, as did, presumably, Petaluma City.[35]

During the recession, founders of both Petaluma and Petaluma City began to depart for greener pastures. Keller was to first to go. In the fall of 1853, he returned to the Midwest, where he joined with a group of developers in co-founding the city of Leavenworth, Kansas. Before leaving town, he granted his lawyer Lewis power of attorney in all future property sales in Petaluma.[36]

Lewis himself ran into financial trouble during the recession, defaulting on a handful of property investments. He left town in 1854, eventually settling in Calaveras County, where he was elected county supervisor.[37]

Heintzelman and Huie continued to operate the Reindeer steamboat until November 1854 when, undercut by Minturn’s new monopoly, the boat was repossessed and sold at auction.[38] The next month, Heintzelman was elected to the state senate, representing Sonoma, Marin, and Mendocino counties. After his term ended in 1856, he departed for Crescent City, where he was appointed government agent for the Klamath Indian Reservation.[39] That same year, Brewster was elected Surveyor General of California and left for Sacramento.[40]

Huie left town shortly thereafter, eventually returning to Kentucky.[41] He passed the development of Petaluma City over to his two sons, J. Thompson Huie, a Petaluma druggist, and Dr. George W. Huie, a Petaluma physician. By then it had failed to develop into much more than a shipping port for farmers and ranchers on the east side of the creek.[42]

In 1855, the Land Commission conferred ownership of the Rancho Arroyo de San Antonio to James F. Stuart, after he cut a deal with Thomas B. Valentine to withdraw his competing claim.

Illustration of James F. Stuart, 1893 (San Francisco Call newspaper)

More than 200 Petaluma landowners forked out $70,000 ($2 million in today’s currency) to repurchase their properties from him. Stuart split the proceeds with Valentine, who, feeling shortchanged, later challenged Stuart’s ownership in court, setting off a complicated legal battle that wasn’t fully resolved until 1874.[43]

1855 illustrated map of Petaluma by L.W. Worth, with an illustration of James F. Stuart’s real estate office at the bottom (Sonoma County Library)

Meanwhile, Petaluma’s economy began to rebound thanks to the Crimean War which cut off Russian wheat exports to Australia and New Zealand, forcing those countries to turn to California.[44] By 1857, the California wheat boom had turned Petaluma into a bustling port town with a population of 1,338. A year later, it incorporated as a city.[45]

But the wheat boom posed a new existential threat to Petaluma. Increased runoff from the farms began to fill the Petaluma Creek with silt, especially at the braided bends near town, making it difficult for steamboats to navigate up into Petaluma.

In 1856, John Rudesill opened a new landing a mile south of Petaluma City on the west bank of the creek, which came to be known as Haystack Landing (today Dutra Material’s asphalt plant). Steamboat passengers disembarked there for stages into town, while freight was offload onto smaller, flat-bottom boats known as “mud stages” able to navigate the shallow waters.[46]

Elliot R. Moffet (Joblin Globe newspaper, 1923)

In 1859, the new City of Petaluma commissioned Elliot R. Moffet, a local businessman and owner of the Rambler steamboat, to cut through two of the largest bends in the creek, including the one leading to the Petaluma City landing.[47] Moffet made the cuts, but not to the satisfaction of the city, which refused to pay him. Saddled with debt, Moffet sold the Rambler and fled town, eventually returning to his home state of Iowa, where he co-founded the town of Joplin, serving as its first mayor.[48]

Illustration of Elliott R. Moffet’s steamboat the Rambler, navigating the Petlauma Creek in the 1850s (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

Moffet’s cut across the bend leading to Petaluma City meant that schooners and steamboats traveling to and from Petaluma now bypassed the Petaluma City landing. That was the final nail in the coffin for New Town. In the early 1860s, Huie’s sons sold off the remaining lots for farmland, and Petaluma City, aka New Town, became history.[49]

1860 U.S. Coast Survey map of Petaluma Creek featuring Rudesill’s Landing (aka Haystack Landing) and Newtown (aka Petaluma City), along with cuts made in the first two oxbow bends in the creek by Elliot Moffet in 1859 (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

In 1862, Charles Minturn undertook a new dredging of the creek from Haystack Landing to a point about a mile north called Italian Garden, across from Petaluma City’s landing. In an unintentional but fitting manner, he retired the former Red Jacket steamboat, now known as the Kate Hayes, at the site to serve as landing and freight dock. He then installed a horse-drawn rail line from Italian Garden to Petaluma.[50]

In 1866, after the creek around Italian Garden began to fill again with silt, Minturn extended his rail line to Haystack Landing. The Red Jacket was left to slowly crumble over the years into the mud, across from where it made its first run to Petaluma City in the steamboat rumble of 1852.[51]

******

Special thanks to Terry Park of the Petaluma Historical Library & Museum for his research assistance. A version of this story appeared in the November 13, 2026, edition of the Petaluma Argus-Courier.


FOOTNOTES:

[1] Robert A. Thompson, A Historical and Descriptive Sketch of Sonoma County (Philadelphia: L.H. Everts & Co., 1877), pps. 55-56.

[2] Thompson, pps. 55-56.

[3] Thompson, pps. 55-56.

[4] Thompson, pps. 55-56.

[5] Thompson, pps. 54-55; J.P. Munro-Fraser, History of Sonoma County (San Francisco: Alley, Bowen & Co., 1880), pgs. 131, 259; “From California,” Letter from James B. Huie, Louisville Courier-Journal, December 24, 1849.

[6] “Farm for Sale,” Daily Alta California, May 17, 1849; “Farms for Sale” ad, Daily Alta California, October 19, 1851; “Farms for Sale” ad, The Nevada Journal, November 6, 1851; “Auction Sales by Henry Fitch & Co.,” Daily Alta California, July 11, 1852.

[7] Kevin Starr, Richard Orsi, eds., Rooted in Barbarous Soil: People, Culture, and Community in Gold Rush California (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press. 2000), pps. 243-248, 278-280; Kevin Starr, California: A History (New York: Modern Library, 2005), pps. 110-111.

[8] Munro-Fraser, pgs. 131, 259.

[9] David Hornbeck, “The Patenting of California’s Private Land Claims, 1851-1885,” Geographical Review, Vol. 69, No. 4 (October., 1979), pgs. 437-438, 443.

[10] Paul W. Gates, 1971, The California Land Act of 1851, California Historical Society, Vol. 50, No. 4 (Dec., 1971), pp. 395–430.

[11] Donald J. Pisani, “Squatter Law in California, 1850-1858,” Western Historical Quarterly, Autumn, 1994, Vol. 25, No. 3, pps. 291-292; Paul W. Gates, The California Land Act of 1851, California Historical Society, Vol. 50, No. 4 (Dec., 1971), pp. 395–430; “The Preemption Act of 1841,” 27th Congress, Ch. 16, 5 Stat. 453 (1841), accessed from www.minnesotalegalhistoryproject.org; Note: the Preemption Act of 1841 gave settlers the right to purchase 160 acres in the public domain, assuming they squatted on the land for at least 14 months, or made agricultural improvements to it for five years.

[12] “General Notices,” Daily Alta California, December 18, 1851.

[13] Munro-Fraser, p. 259; “Settlers’ Association,” Daily Alta California, July 27, 1850; “Mexican War letter describing the Battle of the Sacramento, 1847,” California State Library, California History Room, https://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/001112803

[14] “Pioneer Gone,” Sacramento Union, January 8, 1889; Adair Heig, History of Petaluma (Petaluma, CA: Scottwall Associates, 1982), p. 29; Munro-Fraser, pps. 259-260; Note: In 1855, the Land Commission decreed James Stuart the rightful owner of the Laguna de San Antonio land grant Petaluma sat upon, after which land owners were forced to repurchase their property from him.

[15] Sonoma County Deeds, Liber A, 1843-1853, Page 579 (original page 5), image 720, January 3, 1852; Munro-Fraser, p. 260.

[16] “Historical: Petaluma Birth and Growth,” Petaluma Courier, October 19, 1892; “Capt. Micajah Green Lewis, USA (1803 – 1893),” Geni.com, https://www.geni.com/people/Capt-Micajah-Lewis-USA/6000000121302494821; “Election Notice,” Daily Alta California, September 5, 1855; “Pioneer Gone,” Sacramento Union, January 8, 1889. Note: Brewster was elected on the People’s Party ticket, which advocated for settlers’ rights. He served one term of State Surveyor from 1856 to 1858.

[17] Sonoma County Deeds, Liber A, 1843-1853, Page 579 (original page 5), image 720, January 3, 1852.

[18] “Died in Kentucky,” Petaluma Argus, February 27, 1880; “Law Report,” Daily Alta California, April 25, 1855.

[19] Ed Mannion, “Casa Grande Road Served as Newtown,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, April 20, 1957.

[20] Stephen Silliman, Lost Laborers in Colonial California: Native Americans and the Archaeology of Rancho Petaluma (University of Arizona Press, 2004), p. 13; Allan Rosenus, General M.G. Vallejo and the Advent of the Americans (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1995), p. 212-13.

[21] Ed Mannion, “Casa Grande Road Served as Newtown,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, April 20, 1957; Liber A Deeds, Sonoma County, Page 710-711  (original page 208-209) Sonoma County Deeds: deed sale by Mariano G. Vallejo of Sonoma to M.G. Lewis and Henry P. Heintzelman of Petaluma of “undivided half of the town site of Petaluma” as laid down in map by C.W. Rowe. Lewis and Heintzelman to hold even numbered lots, and Vallejo odd numbered lots. Lewis and Heintzelman also deposit an undivided interest in said town to James B. Huie. Signed by Vallejo, Lewis, Heintzelman, and Huie.

[22] Deeds, Liber M, Sonoma County, Pages 171-173  (original page 197-198) Sonoma County Deeds: On July 9, 1852, M.G. Lewis sells James B. Huie for $1,000 his interest in 600 acres known as the City of Petaluma mapped out by Wesley Rowe, being a piece of the parcel conveyed by Mariano G. Vallejo to Lewis and H. P. Heintzelman in deed on June 12, 1852. Lewis reserves for himself 7 lots of 80×100 feet each; Note: Lewis also made an unsuccessful run for the state senate in 1852 (“From the Interior: Sonoma,” Sacramento Daily Union, October 4, 1852; “Election Returns—Sonoma County,” Sacramento Union, November 27, 1852).

[23] Deeds, Liber M, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 3, image 230: September 20, 1852, ownership of lots 10 and 12, which on the 1852 Rowe map are beside the creek, in what appears to be marsh land: James B. Huie and Henry P. Heintzelman, joint owners of lots numbered 10 and 12 in Petaluma City, in consideration for one dollar each paid to the other, Lot 10 shall be divided into lots 80 feet, each fronting Front Street and running to the Petaluma Creek. Huie shall have the corner lot situated at Main & Front streets, the adjacent lot granted to Henry P. Heintzelman, and each remaining alternative lot in subdivision is granted to the two parties. The remaining part of Lot 12 running back to Petaluma Creek shall remain for the use of a ferry, owned by James B. Huie, the remaining part of Lot 12 owned by Heintzelman; Munro-Fraser, p. 260: location of Hertzelmann’s office.

[24] Deeds, Liber M, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 267, image 366: On August 1, 1852, M.G. Lewis, serving as attorney on behalf of George H. Keller and “signing in fact” for Keller, for the sum of $150 sold lots 17 and 18 in Petaluma to Samuel Terrill (a fellow Justice of the Peace); Deeds, Liber M, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 207, image 335: On July 24, 1853, M.G. Lewis, serving as attorney on behalf of George H. Keller and “signing in fact” for Keller, for the sum of $80, sold three lots in Petaluma to James Delaney.

[25] “Land Commission: Claims Filed Since Last Report,” Sacramento Daily Union, June 3, 1852.

[26] Thompson, pp. 55-56.

[27] Ad for sailing yacht Gen. Geo. Cadwallader, Daily Alta California, May 18, 1850: Huie was engaged in the ferry business in San Francisco; “Died in Kentucky,” Petaluma Argus, February 27, 1880.

[28a] “Petaluma River Watershed,” City of Petaluma.com, https://cityofpetaluma.org/petaluma-river-watershed/; “City of Petaluma,” My Topo.com, https://geo.mytopo.com/feature/california/sonoma/civil/2411407/city-of-petaluma/; “Petaluma Valley Historical Hydrology and Ecology Study,” San Francisco Estuary Institute-Aquatic Science Center (SFEI), 2018, pgs. 38, 45-47. https://www.sfei.org/sites/default/files/biblio_files/Petaluma%20Historical%20Ecology%20med%20res.pdf

[28] Ad for Red Jacket, Daily Alta California, August 14, 1852; “Notice,” Daily Alta California, September 14, 1852; Ads for Red Jacket, Daily California Alta, September 24, 25, 26, 27, 30 1852, October 1, 1862; “Died in Kentucky,” Petaluma Argus, February 27, 1880: Huie’s obituary gives him credit for running the first steamer up the Petaluma Creek; Heig, p. 71.

[29] “The Gale Yesterday—Accidents in the Harbor,” Daily Alta California, November 4, 1852.

[30] Ad “For Petaluma,” Daily Alta California, March 2, 1853; “Notice, Daily Alta California, May 27, 1853; Ad for Reindeer Steamer for Petaluma, Daily Alta California, October 13, 1853; “From the Interior: Sonoma,” Sacramento Daily Union, July 28, 1853.

[31] First Ad for steamer E. Corning to Petaluma, Daily Alta California, October 27, 1853.

[32] Wilbur Hoffman, “When Steamers Sailed the Feather,” Sutter County Historical Society News Bulletin, Vol. XVIII, April 1979; Jerry McMullen, Paddle Wheel Days in California (Stanford University Press, 1944), pp. 17-19.

[33] Minturn ad for newly refitted Kate Hayes for Vallejo and Napa route, Daily Alta California, January 10, 1853; Ad for Kate Hayes for Petaluma, Daily Alta California, March 31, 1854; “Historical: Petaluma’s Birth and Growth,” Petaluma Courier, October 19, 1892.

[34] “Commercial Depression 1854,” FoundSF.org, https://www.foundsf.org/COMMERCIAL_DEPRESSION_1854

[35] Thompson, p. 56. Note: Thompson provides the population figure, but avoids any mention of the recession, instead promoting a tale of rising prosperity.

[36] Henry Miles Moore, “Sketches of the Early Settlement of the City and County of Leavenworth,” Western Life (Leavenworth, KS), August 3, 1900; Deeds, Liber A, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 833 (original page 93), image 842: on October 26, 1853, Keller grants Lewis power of attorney in all his real estate transactions in Petaluma. Note: it appears that Keller’s son, Garret V. Keller, who remained in Petaluma for a few years, also handled some property sales after his father’s departure.

[37] “Election Returns,” San Andreas Independent, September 4, 1858; “Postal Affairs,” Sacramento Union, August 18, 1884; Deeds, Liber M, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 149, image 304; “Sheriff’s Sale,” Petaluma Journal, August 18, 1855; Note: In 1853, Lewis purchased 160 acres from Bartholomew Bojoques for $1,000 on the road to Bodega. In 1855, that property was part of a liquidation sale to pay off Lewis’s debts.

[38] Sheriff’s Sale,” Daily Alta California, November 11, 1854; Auction sale of Reindeer, Sacramento Daily Union, December 2, 1854; “Ellen Craig,” Petaluma Journal, December 15, 1855; Note: Apparently a lawsuit between Huie and John W. Brittan led to the sheriff seizing control of the Reindeer and selling it at auction. The new owners of the Reindeer it running to Petaluma and Petaluma City for another year before replacing it with the steamer Ellen Craig.

[39] Edwin C. Bearss, “Chapter 6: The Establishment of the Klamath River Reservation,” History Basic Data, Redwood National Park, Del Norte and Humboldt Counties, California, U.S. Department of Interior, September 1, 1969. https://npshistory.com/publications/redw/history/chap6.htm; “Office of Klamath Indian Reservation ,July 13, 1857,” California Indian History, https://calindianhistory.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/07_13_1857.pdf; 1855 letter from Heintzelman to Congressman James W. Denver, December 19, 1855, Bartlebys Books.com, https://www.bartlebysbooks.com/pages/books/66219/h-p-heintzelman/reporting-on-the-political-climate-in-sacramento-the-candidates-for-california-secretary-of; Note: During his senate term Heintzelman undertook a survey of Sonoma and Mendocino native tribes for the Department of Indian Affairs.

[40] “Pioneer Gone,” Sacramento Union, January 8, 1889.

[41] “Religious,” Sonoma County Journal, August 2, 1856: the last listing of Huie in Petaluma, where he chaired a group creating St. John’s Episcopal Church.

[42] Ad for George and J. Thompson Huie selling hay at Petaluma City warehouse, Sonoma County Journal, January 29, 1858; Ad for shipping service out of New Town, Sonoma County Journal, August 26, 1859; Ad for 2 large warehouses and a number of lots sold in New Town, Sonoma County Journal, August 20, 1858; Ad for Real Estate for Sale, Sonoma County Journal, October 23, 1863; “Death of a Former Resident,” Petaluma Courier, December 13, 1893.

[43] Deeds, Liber M, 1852-1855, Sonoma County, Pg. 221, image 342, May 16, 1853: Keller ironically sold Stuart a lot in Petaluma in 1853; “The First Fight of the Lobby,” Petaluma Argus, February 25, 1863; “The Miranda Resolutions,” Sonoma County Journal, February 27, 1863; W.W. Robinson, Land in California: The Story of Mission Lands (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1948), pp. 178-179.

[44] Donald Pisani, From the Family Farm to Agribusiness (Berkeley: UC Press, 1984), p. 5-10; James Gerber, “The Gold Rush Origins of California’s Wheat Economy,” December 2010, America Latina en la Historia Economica, 17(34):37-66; James Gerber, “Gold Rushes and the Trans-Pacific Wheat Trade, California and Australia, 1848-57,” Pacific and Pacific Rim Economic History Since the 16th Century, edited by Dennis O. Flynn, A.J. H. Lathan, and Lionell Frost (NJ: Routledge, 1999).

[45] Robert A. Thompson, pg. 56.

[46] First ads for Rudesill’s Landing, also called Haystack Landing: “New Coach,” Petaluma Journal, June 7, 1856; Ad , Petaluma Journal, June 14, 1856; Ad for Kate Hayes, Petaluma Journal, June 21, 1856; “Engines, Mules on Haystack Line,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 17, 1955: use of small boats for shuttling freight from Haystack Landing; Honoria Tuomey, History of Sonoma County (Chicago: S.J. Clarke Publishing Company, 1926), Vol, 1, p. 471: Petaluma’s “mud stages.’

[47] “Act to Improve the Creek,” Sonoma County Journal, April 13, 1860; “The Work Commenced,” Sonoma County Journal, August 26, 1859; “Improvement of the Creek,” Sonoma County Journal, October 14, 1859.

[48] “Steamboat Changes,” Sonoma County Journal, November 25, 1859; Not Dead,” Daily National Democrat, December 6, 1859; “He Served as the First Mayor of Joplin Through Appointment,” Joplin Globe, June 10, 1923.”

[49] Ad for 2 large warehouses and a number of lots sold for sale in New Town, Sonoma County Journal, August 20, 1858; Ad for Real Estate at Auction, Sonoma County Journal, October 15, 1858; Ad for Real Estate for Sale, Sonoma County Journal, October 23, 1863; Ad for J. Thompson Huie’s 320-acre Farm for Sale, Sonoma County Journal, September 22, 1864; Ad announcing closing of J.T. Huie & Co. pharmacy, Petaluma Argus, January 31, 1867; “Serious Accident,” Petaluma Argus, March 3, 1876: Huie closes his pharmacy in Petaluma, and presumably the land at New Town, and moves to Fort Point in the Presidio to serve as Lighthouse Keeper.

[50] “Straightening the Creek,” Sonoma County Journal, February 11, 1862; “The Cars are Coming,” Sonoma County Journal, February 19, 1862; “Kate Hayes,” Sonoma County Journal, April 11, 1862; “Projected Enterprises,” Sonoma County Journal, June 13, 1862; “Finished,” Petaluma Argus, July 21, 1864; “Railroad Extension,” Petaluma Argus, May 17, 1866; “Engines, Mules on Haystack Line,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 17, 1955.

[51] “The Old Steamboat Days,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 17, 1955.


Who Built This House: 335 Bassett Street

The Hart House, 335 Bassett Street, built in 1906 (photo John Sheehy)

This hip-roofed, craftsman cottage near the corner of Bassett and Fair streets was built in 1906 by George Weber and A.H. Pape for Ellis O. Hart and his new bride Susan Dubin.[1]

Ellis was born in 1883 and reared on a farm in Lakeville. His father, Blair Hart, was elected in 1900 as Sonoma County supervisor for District 1, which extended east from Penngrove and Lakeville to the Sonoma Valley. Blair would remain a county supervisor until the year before his death at 84 in 1939.[2]

Sonoma County Supervisor Blair Hart, 1908 (Sonoma County Library)

After graduating from Petaluma High, Ellis Hart started working in 1903 for the Golden Eagle Milling Company as a bookkeeper.[3]

Golden Eagle Mill and offices, East Washington and Copeland streets (Sonoma County Library)

Located at East Washington and Copeland streets, the mill was founded in 1884 by two Canadian brothers, Walter and Samuel Percival, with investments from local capitalists. During the 1870s, Walter operated a flour mill in Bloomfield. In 1888, the Percivals sold the Golden Eagle Mill to Petaluma capitalist Hiram T. Fairbanks, and relocated to San Francisco to start a real estate firm.[4]

Ellis Hart married his Lakeville sweetheart, Susan Dubin, in 1906. In January 1907, the couple moved into their newly constructed cottage at 335 Bassett Street, constructed on one of a series of lots along Fair Street owned by Blair Hart. A week later, Susan gave birth to their daughter Lorraine.[5]

Hart’s hip-roof cottage at 335 Bassett Street (Sonoma County Library)
1900 Map and Guide of Petlauma. Arrow points to site of the Hart house, and a group of lots owned by Blair Hart (Sonoma County Library)

A number of other houses were being erected on the block at that time (including 322 and 326 Bassett built by my great-grandmother Julia Casey; and 315, 317, and 321 Bassett built by my other great-grandmother, Hannah Sheehy, who in the late 1880s owned the entire south side of Bassett Street between Baker and Fair streets). Petaluma High School would not be constructed at the end of the block on Fair Street until 1915.[6]

1915 view of Bassett Street from Fair Street to St. Vincent’s de Paul Church; arrow points to Hart house (photo public domain)

The builders of the Harts’s new home, Weber and Pape of Santa Rosa, had contracted to construct the cottage for $1,550 ($55,000 in today’s currency). They charged them an additional $344, claiming Ellis had agreed orally to the increase. Ellis took them to court, arguing theirs was a false claim, and won.[7]

Soon after building his house, Ellis was promoted to general manager at the Golden Eagle Mill, and secretary of its board of directors, positions he would hold until 1953. The Golden Eagle Mill was destroyed by a fire in 1968, and replaced by today’s River Plaza Shopping Center.[8]

Susan and Ellis Hart standing behind their daughter Lorraine at her wedding to Eugene Holdenried, 1935 (Sonoma Count Library)

In 1935, the Harts hired A. Mariam Seeberg, a popular Norwegian architect and contractor in Petaluma, to remodel their cottage, adding an addition above the garage.[9]

Ellis and his wife Susan lived together at that the cottage until his death in 1963 at age 80. Susan remained there until her death in 1973 at age 87.[10]

Hart house, 335 Bassett Street (courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway)

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “Were Wedded on Tuesday,” Petaluma Argus, July 10, 1906 “Briefs,” Petaluma Courier, January 17, 1907; Ellis Hart Won Suit,” Petaluma Argus, February 14, 1908.

[2] “Jottings,” Petaluma Courier, October 15, 1879; “Baudau’s Election as County Assessor Seems Assured with Count Near End,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, November 19, 1938; “Blair Hart, Petaluma, Dean of Sonoma Supervisors,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 24, 1939. Note: Blair Hart was elected supervisor for District 1 from 1900 to 1912. Then he and his wife moved into Petaluma, and he was elected supervisor for District 2 from 1916 to 1938.

[3] “Local Brevities,” Petaluma Courier, July 22, 1903; “Soon to be Married,” Petaluma Courier, July 7, 1906; “Obituaries: Ellis O. Hart,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 30, 1963.

[4] “Our Real Estate Transactions,” Petaluma Argus, March 8, 1872; “Bloomfield Industries,” Petaluma Argus, October 31, 1873; “A Disastrous Fire,” Petaluma Courier, December 24, 1884; “$19,500,” Petaluma Courier, December 31, 1884; “The Golden Eagle Flouring Mills,” Petaluma Courier, July 1, 1885; “New Officers,” Petaluma Argus, January 7, 1888; “Petition,” Petaluma Argus, April 21, 1888; “Courierlets,” Petaluma Courier, July 4, 1888; “Death Calls W. Percival, Sr.” Petaluma Argus, January 25, 1926; “Golden Eagle Employs Many,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, August 17, 1955.

[5] “Were Wedded on Tuesday,” Petaluma Argus, July 10, 1906; Briefs,” Petaluma Courier, January 17, 1907; “Briefs,” Petaluma Courier, January 22, 1907; “Born,” Petaluma Argus, January 22, 1907; 1900 street map of Petlauma, Sonoma County Library.

[6] “Bassett Street Improvements,” Petaluma Courier, April 14, 1909.

[7] “Residence Being Completed,” Santa Rosa Republican, March 22, 1906; “Court Calendar,” Petaluma Courier, December 17, 1907; “Ellis Hart Won Suit,” Petaluma Argus, February 14, 1908.

[8] “Annual Meeting,” Petaluma Courier, June 11, 1908; “Cargo Will Be a Total Loss,” Petaluma Courier, August 20, 1910; “Obituaries: Ellis O. Hart,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 30, 1963.

“Fire Sweeps Golden Eagle Milling Plant,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, July 5, 1968.

[9] “Okay Building Permits in City,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 24, 1935.

[10] “Obituaries: Ellis O. Hart,”  Petaluma Argus-Courier, September 30, 1963; “Obituary: Susan D. Hart,” Petaluma Argus-Courier, June 26, 1973.

Christo’s Trojan Horse

HOW THE RUNNING FENCE SUBVERSIVELY CHANGED SONOMA COUNTY

The Running Fence , September 8-22, 1976 (photo by Wolfgang Volz, Sonoma County Library)

Fences have long symbolized division. So it came as little surprise that when two artists arrived in Petaluma in early 1974 proposing an installation called Running Fence, they faced immediate resistance.

Christo and Jeanne-Claude claimed their project—an 18-foot-high nylon fence stretching 24.5 miles over the countryside from Cotati to the coast near Bodega Bay—would foster “togetherness” by offering people a new way of seeing the local landscape.

Instead, their proposal became a lightning rod in a turf war over land use, pitting outside developers against environmentalists. From their headquarters at the Petaluma Inn, Bulgarian-born Christo and Moroccan-born Jeanne-Claude played that division to their advantage.

That included more than two years of navigating 18 public hearings, three Superior Court sessions, and a 465-page environmental impact report. As the proceedings dragged on, Christo made it clear their true work of art was not the physical installation, but the process of bringing it into being.

“You are all part of our work,” he explained in his thick Bulgarian accent.

The artist Christo beside his Running Fence (photo by Morrie Camhi)

Yet despite their pledge of fostering unity, Christo and Jeanne-Claude strategically aligned themselves with one side of the local divide—a loose coalition of developers, anti-tax activists, and ranchers united by their common desire to loosen land-use restrictions.

That included restrictions on absurd art installations like Running Fence, which few members of the coalition pretended to understand. Most viewed it as a useful proxy.

A major hurdle Christo and Jeanne-Claude faced was convincing ranchers to allow the fence to extend across their properties. At first, their foreign accents, New York avant-garde airs, and hippie appearances clashed with the conservative, no-nonsense ranching community. It wasn’t until Valley Ford sheep rancher Lester Bruhn realized there was a financial payoff for cash-strapped ranchers that doors began to open.

Sheep rancher Lester Bruhn (photo by Gianfranco Gorgoni, copyright Christo and Jeanne-Claude Foundation)

With Bruhn’s help, Christo and Jeanne-Claude secured leases from 59 ranchers, backed by a team of lawyers who negotiated lease fees. Modest ranches were offered $200 (about $1,200 in today’s currency), while a large ranch received $5,500 (roughly $32,000 today). Ranchers were also promised the fence’s nylon curtains, metal posts, and cables after the installation came down.

Christo and Jeanne-Claude took a similar approach with the conservative Sonoma County Taxpayers Association. “They came to us hat in hand, money in pocket,” said association president Jim Groom. “We like that.”

The one constituency the couple made little effort to court was the art community. “Local artists,” Jeanne-Claude said, “saw us as an invasion of their turf.”

Jeanne-Claude (photo by Wolfgang Volz, copyright Christo and Jeanne-Claude Foundation)

Many, in fact, condemned Running Fence as a gimmick. Others criticized it as “fascist art” for dominating, rather than complementing, the landscape. Ironically, their opposition helped by shifting media attention away from the tedious debates about land-use policy to a more theatrical—but pointless—debate over what constitutes public art.

For, while Christo described Running Fence as “public art,” there was actually little public about it. Built by paid crews on private land, its $3 million price tag (about $17 million today) was privately financed through the sale of Christo’s artwork. Despite his claims that everyone was part of the process, it was not subjected to reviews by public art commissions.

Like a visiting carnival, Running Fence’s only formal review was the county’s land-use permitting process. That placed it squarely in the headlights of a legal battle drawing national attention: Petaluma’s effort to limit growth.

Christo at public hearing for Running Fence, 1975 (photo by Gianfranco Gorgoni, copyright Christo and Jeanne-Claude Foundation)

By the early 1970s, a post-war, suburban housing boom had quadrupled Petaluma’s population. With the city’s infrastructure overwhelmed, the city council capped new residential construction at 500 houses per year. Developers sued. In February 1976, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review a lower-court ruling upholding the cap, making Petaluma the darling of slow-growth advocates across the country.

Savvy developers, however, had already shifted their focus to the largely unregulated countryside. A flashpoint was the proposed 994-unit housing subdivision on the Watson Ranch, a 1,000-acre dairy north of Petaluma at Stony Point and Pepper roads, near where Christo was planning to begin Running Fence.

The ranch was operated by John Keegan Watson, a second-generation dairyman. Squeezed by rising property taxes, in 1970 he sold a controlling interest in the property to Palo Alto developers. It wasn’t his only option. Under the Williamson Act of 1965, he could have reduced his tax burden by restricting his land to agriculture use or open space.

Cows grazing outside house on the Watson Ranch, Pepper Road (photo Sonoma County Library)

But those tax benefits weren’t enough for struggling dairymen like Watson in the increasingly unstable dairy industry. State-imposed pricing caps, declining demand due to cholesterol dietary concerns, and a punishing two-year drought were all taking their toll.

The clincher was California’s new, environmental waste-treatment rules, which required dairies to make costly upgrades by 1977. For a number of ranchers, the only viable option was to sell, either to a larger dairy or to developers.

Opposition to local suburban sprawl meanwhile was gaining momentum. One of the leading opponents was Dr. Bill Kortum, a Petaluma large-animal veterinarian who lived on his family’s former chicken ranch near Denman flats. Elected in 1974 to the Sonoma County Board of Supervisors, he proposed establishing greenbelts between incorporated cities to prevent wall-to-wall subdivisions. His proposal was incorporated into a draft of the county’s new general plan.

Sonoma County Supervisor Dr. Bill Kortum (photo Santa Rosa Press Democrat)

As the three-year planning process unfolded, Kortum and fellow board member Chuck Hinkle pushed for a moratorium on new lot splits. Developers responded with a recall campaign. As their attack dog, they enlisted fellow developer and president of the Sonoma County Taxpayers Association, Jim Groom.

Publicly, Groom positioned the recall as a protest against the supervisors’ support for a recent property tax increase. Privately, he warned ranchers that greenbelts would depress land values and eliminate their rainy-day option of selling to developers.

Jim Groom, developer and president of the Sonoma County Taxpayers Association (photo Sonoma County Library)

In the midst of the recall campaign, Christo appeared before the Board of Supervisors seeking final approval for Running Fence. Kortum cast the lone dissenting vote, concerned the installation would open the door to further exceptions—billboards, concert venues, carnivals, motorcycle tracks— on protected farmland.

Pro-growth supervisors brushed aside his concern. One observed that a fence—running or not—was, by definition, “agricultural.”

Running Fence installation (photo by Wolfgang Volz, Sonoma County Library)

In April 1976, Christo and Jeanne-Claude broke ground on Lester Bruhn’s Valley Ford ranch. A month later, Kortum and Hinkle were recalled in a special election. Developers of the Watson Ranch subdivision, seeing an opening, submitted their plans to the Sonoma County Planning Commission.

On September 8, 1976, Running Fence’s two-week exhibit opened in dramatic defiance of government regulators. Months earlier, the California Coastal Commission had rescinded approval of running the fence’s final 1,000 yards across protected coastal land. Christo’s lawyers appealed, and a new hearing was set for September 23rd—the day after the exhibit was scheduled to come down.

To the delight of his supporters, Christo ordered his workers to extend the fence across the protected land into the sea. A San Francisco art critic called the “illegal leap” a violation of both the law and the spirit of the artwork. Christo disagreed.

Running Fence’s “illegal leap” into the Pacific Ocean at Bodega Bay (photo by Wolfgang Volz, Sonoma County Library)

“Illegality is essential to the American system, don’t you see?” he told The New Yorker. “I completely work within the American system by being illegal, like everyone else—if there is no illegal part, the project is less reflective of the system. It’s the subversive character of the system that makes it so exciting to live here.”

The day after Running Fence’s opening, about 700 developers, anti-tax activists, and regional Republican leaders gathered in Santa Rosa to honor Groom as citizen of the year for his role in recalling Kortum and Hinkle. A congratulatory telegram from President Gerald Ford was read aloud.

Over the next two weeks, Running Fence transformed the Sonoma and Marin dairylands into an open-air museum, its billowing white nylon panels rippling across the hills and valleys. Christo called it “a ribbon of light.” An estimated two million people came to view it. Many found the sight far more beautiful than expected.

Running Fence (photo Wolfgang Volz, Sonoma County Library)

Despite the brief mark it made on the land, Running Fence helped to reshape the region’s political alignment. That became evident two months later, when voters reversed the political outcome of the recall, electing a growth-control majority to the Board of Supervisors. The board adopted a new general plan emphasizing concentrated city growth, limited rural development, and preservation of agricultural land.

“I’m convinced the fence was a major factor,” recalled Brian Kahn, one of the newly elected supervisors. “It made people think about the land and their relationship to it.”

Among the casualties was the Watson Ranch subdivision. The Sonoma County Land Trust purchased development rights to the property, helping to establish a permanent greenbelt between Petaluma and Cotati.

As for Christo’s and Jeanne-Claude’s supporting coalition of developers, anti-tax activists, and ranchers, Running Fence proved to be a Trojan horse—an enduring reminder that the power of art lies not only in its beauty, but in its subversive nature.

Jeanne-Claude and Christo in front of Running Fence’s ending at the ocean (photo by Morrie Camhi, copyright Christo and Jeanne-Claude Foundation)

******

A version of this story appeared in the Petaluma Argus-Courier May 22, 2026

_______

SOURCES:

Colby Chamberlain, “The Politics of Christo and Jeanne-Claude’s Running Fence,” Artforum, April 2017.

Coastwalk California: “Bill Kortum—His Story,” December, 2014, https://coastwalk.org/bill-kortum-his-story/

Los Angeles Times: “Petaluma is Doing ‘Just Fine’ After 17 Years of Controls,” April 11, 1988.

Eric Stanley, “Christo: Legacy Remembered,” Museum of Sonoma County, June 9, 2020. https://museumsc.org/christo-legacy-remembered/

New York Times: “Christo, Artist Known for Massive, Fleeting Displays, Dies,” May 31, 2020.

Calvin Tompkins, “Onward and Upward with the Arts: Running Fence,” The New Yorker, March 28, 1977.

Petaluma Argus-Courier: “John S. Watson—One of State’s Prime Movers,” January 12, 1963; “Dairying Isn’t the Quiet, Easy Life it Once Was,” July 28, 1973; “Ag Problems: Local Dairy May Move After 32 Years,” April 21, 1976; “Christo’s Fence Now Under Construction,” May 4, 1976; “Dairies Feeling the Water Pinch,” June 11, 1976; “Planners: House Report Had Holes,” August 25, 1976; “Late Housing Report Draws Criticism,” August 18, 1976; “Petaluma Farms Draws Criticism at Hearing,” September 3, 1976; “Fence Triggers Debate,” September 11, 1976; “Opposition Defeats Subdivision,” September 17, 1976; “Fence Artist is Gone,” September 30, 1976; “Fence in Demand for Souvenirs,” October 4, 1976; “Another Dairy Closes,” March 3, 1977; “Open Space, Park EDP Changes Studied,” July 13, 1978; “Obituary: John Keegan Watson,” May 29, 1979; “Watson Ranch Remains Open Land Under Trust,” December 10, 1979; “Environmental Icon’s Legacy Remembered,” December 25, 2014.

San Francisco Examiner: “Good for Business, But is it Art?” September 9, 1976.

San Rafael Daily Independent Journal: “Christo’s Fence Granted Sonoma Board’s Approval,” May 19, 1975.

Santa Rosa Press Democrat: “A ‘Running Fence,’” January 21, 1974; “Supervisors Clear Christo’s Fence,” March 19, 1975; “Christo’s Fence Clears Coast Committee,” April 25, 1975; “Groom, SCTA Supported,” September 17, 1975; “Kortum Vows to Defeat Recall,” December 17, 1975; “Second District,” May 26, 1976; “Kortum: An Opportunist’s Cop-out,” June 2, 1976; “Christo’s $2 Million Fence Almost Reader for Sept. 8 Hanging,” August 30, 1976; “Christo’s Fence Takes Illegal Dip,” September 8, 1976; Gaye LeBaron column, September 12, 1976; “Ford Praises Groom as Citizen of Year,” September 12, 1976; “Delong Bitter Blast at General Plan, Kahn,” January 11, 1978; “Jim Groom Still Packs a Mean Punch,” June 23, 1993; “Christo, Famed Environmental Artist Behind ‘Running Fence’ in Sonoma and Marin counties, Dies at 84,” (pickup from Washington Post), May 31, 2020.

Smithsonian Magazine: “Q&A: Christo and Jeanne-Claude,” December, 2008; “Christo’s California Dreamin’,” June 2010.

Sonoma Magazine: Glen Martin, “Christo’s Running Fence: Photos, Stories, and Memories,” June, 2020.

Sonoma West Times and News: “Running Fence Has its Problems,” July 26, 1976; “Artists Speak from Both Sides of the Fence,” July 26, 1976; “Recall Elections, New Faces Were Part of the County’s First General Plan Debates,” August 15, 2007.

Caitlin O’Hara, “The Journey to the Running Fence,” UC Press Blog, https://www.ucpress.edu/blog/9847/the-journey-to-running-fence/

Brian Doherty, et al, Remembering the Running Fence (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2010).

Anne Schuhart, “Keeping Dairy Waste Under Control,” Soil Conservation, Volume 43; Volumes 1977-1978 (Information Division, Soil Conservation Service, 1977), pp. 15-17.

Running Fence, film documentary by Albert Maysles, David Maysles, and Charlotte Zwerin, 1977.

Ripe for the Taking: Petaluma’s Fruit Canning Days

Illustration of the Petaluma Fruit Packing Co. Plant, 1887 (courtesy of Jim Bower Collection)

In 1882, a serial entrepreneur named Joseph J. Groom came to Petaluma with a juicy proposition to open a fruit cannery. Not only would it be an instant money maker, he claimed it would also transform the city into a major fruit basket of the world.[1]  

Petaluma was ripe for the taking. Growth in the once thriving river port had stagnated since 1870, when the new San Francisco & Northern Pacific Railroad shifted the region’s main agricultural shipping hub to Santa Rosa. A five-year national recession that followed in the mid-1870s, along with the collapse of California’s wheat boom—an engine of local prosperity since the late 1850s, further stymied Petaluma’s growth.[2]

Canning offered the attractive aroma of industrialization. No longer would fruit and vegetables be left to rot in the fields due to market fluctuations in supply and demand. Processed into canned fruit, jams, jellies, preserves, pickles, catsups, and sauces, they would be profitably exported around the world in tins.

The first west coast cannery factories—the San Jose Fruit Packing Company and the Golden Gate Cannery—opened in the Santa Clara Valley during the early 1870s.[3]

Golden Gate Cannery label (courtesy of History San Jose.com)

A co-founder of the Golden Gate Cannery, Groom became a tin-can evangelist in the early 1880s, leading the launch of new canneries in Santa Barbara and Los Angeles.[4] He came to Petaluma at the invitation of two of the area’s leading fruit growers, John W. Cassidy and Francis DeLong.

Both Cassidy and DeLong made their way to California during the gold rush. In 1853, Cassidy co-founded the state’s first nursery in Oakland, importing 50,000 fruit trees from the east coast. In 1858, he moved to Petaluma, creating a 20-acre orchard at the northwestern outskirts of the city. He planted 4,000 fruit trees, the majority of them cherries, after which his orchard became known as Cherry Hill.[5] In 1874, he invented a new fruit dryer and opened a fruit drying plant in town, only to watch it burn down within a month.[6]

John W. Cassidy’s Cherry Hill orchard (Sonoma County Atlas, Thompson & Co., 1877)

Francis DeLong was a land baron. After operating a hardware store in San Francisco, in 1856 he and an orchardist named Joseph Sweetser purchased 8,871-acres of the Rancho de Novato just south of Petaluma.[7]

Francis DeLong (History of Marin County, Allen, Bowen & Co., 1880)

Over time they expanded the ranch to 15,000 acres, leasing much of it to dairy ranchers. On 250 acres they planted 30,000 fruit trees, most of them apples, creating one of the largest orchards in the state. In 1879, DeLong bought out Sweetser, and brought on his 36-year-old son, Frank, Jr., as a partner.[8]

Illustration of Francis DeLong’s Novato Rancho, 1878 (public domain)

A year after Groom’s visit to Petaluma, DeLong and Cassidy joined with four local capitalists—A.P. Whitney, John Fritsch, H.T. Fairbanks, and Conrad Poehlman—to build a cannery along the Petaluma River at First and F streets.[9] With Groom overseeing the launch, the Petaluma Fruit Packing Company opened in time for the 1883 harvest season, which extended from June through December.[10]

In its first year of operation, the cannery generated about $100,000 in revenue ($3.2 million in today’s currency).[11] Of its initial 100 employees, 60 were women and teenaged girls, cannery operators having recognized their “domestic” skills in sorting, cutting, slicing, and preparing fruit. Fourteen Chinese men operated the tin-making shop, and 26 European immigrants manned the warehouse.[12]

Healdsburg’s Magnolia Cannery (Courtesy of the Healdsburg Museum & Historical Society)

Groom left the company after its first year to launch a new cannery in Napa. He was replaced by Delmar E. Ashby, who had worked for San Francisco’s largest cannery, A. Lusk & Co.[13] By 1885, the Petaluma cannery was operating at full capacity. That same year, DeLong died, leaving an estate of $650,000 ($22 million in today’s currency) to his son Frank, Jr.[14]

Frank DeLong, Jr. (findagrave.com)

Frank had been elected the year before to the California state Senate. Flush with his new inheritance, he bought out Cassidy and the cannery’s other seed investors, and formed a new partnership, DeLong, Ashby & Co., with Ashby and a San Francisco fruit broker. He then expanded the cannery to encompass the entire riverside block of First Street between F and G streets.[15]

Petaluma Fruit Packing Company, First & F streets, 1888 Sanborn map

By the late 1880s, the Petaluma Fruit Packing Company was on its way to becoming one of the leading canneries on the west coast. With 500 seasonal workers, it was annually exporting 2 million cans of fruit and vegetables around the world.[16]

DeLong, Ashby & Co. can of Crawford peaches, a small, yellow-skinned freestone peach known for its intense , aromatic and rich flavor (courtesy of Dan Brown Collection)

New canneries were also springing up in Healdsburg, Sebastopol, and Santa Rosa, the largest of which would become the Hunt Brothers, predecessors of Hunt’s Ketchup.[17]

Inspired by the cannery’s success, Petaluma capitalist John A. McNear set out to create a Factory District along the banks of the Petaluma River. To lure factories up from San Francisco and Oakland, he offered inexpensive land, generous financing, and easy shipping via his newly-dredged McNear Canal. In 1892, he persuaded the Carlson-Currier Company to build a major silk mill across the river from the cannery.[18]

Carlson-Currier Silk Mill, Petaluma early 1900s (Sonoma County Library)

With the cannery and silk mill serving as industrial pillars, Petaluma began marketing itself as the North Bay’s new manufacturing center.[19] In 1893, that campaign stumbled when the Petaluma Fruit Packing Company abruptly shut its doors during harvest season.[20]

Senator Frank DeLong, Jr. might have inherited his father’s money, but not his business acumen. With a proclivity for extravagance, the senator spent his inheritance on mansions, show horses, lavish parties, and every new-fangled idea that came his way.[21] His house of cards all came tumbling down during the financial panic of 1893, leaving him half a million of dollars in debt ($18 million today’s currency). Three Petaluma lenders—Isaac Wickersham, William Hill, and George P. McNear—were among those left holding the bag.[22]

Liens were placed on all of DeLong’s assets, including the Petaluma Fruit Packing Company. Attempts were made to reopen the cannery, but potential investors worried their money would be confiscated by creditors.[23]

Vacant former Petaluma Fruit Packing Company plant, 1st & F streets, early 1900s (Petaluma Historical Library & Museum)

The cannery sat vacant until 1906, when Heynemann & Company, manufacturers of “Can’t Bust ‘Em” overalls, purchased the plant after losing their San Francisco factory in the earthquake that year.[24]

Pre-1907 Label for Hyenemann & Co. overalls (public domain)

Heynemann later purchased an adjacent block upon which to build a second plant, but was unable to find sufficient bedrock to support a concrete building. In 1913, the firm moved back to San Francisco, selling the plant to George P. McNear, who converted it into warehouses.[25]

Senator DeLong died penniless.[26] Cassidy meanwhile expanded his Cherry Hill orchard to encompass 53 acres. By the mid-1880s, he was surrounded by a dozen other small fruit orchards on an additional 50 acres of what became known as Cherry Valley. [26a]

In 1894, Cassidy successfully sued the Hunt Brothers for manufacturing fruit drying machines based on his 1874 patent.[27] He and Petaluma capitalist William Hill then raised $100,000 ($3.5 million in today’s currency) to launch the Sonoma County Fruit Company, which brokered the export of fruit to the east coast.[28]

Cassidy’s house at Cherry Hill, then and now (1877 illustration Sonoma County Atlas, 2026 photo courtesy of Scott Hess)

With the cannery’s demise, Petaluma’s dream of becoming a manufacturing center was overtaken in the 1890s by a local poultry boom. Using an efficient egg incubator invented by Petaluma dentist Isaac Dias, Two Rock rancher Chris Nisson industrialized chicken ranching by establishing America’s first commercial hatchery.[29]

The resulting poultry boom rejuvenated Petaluma’s economy. Instead of becoming the “World’s Fruit Basket,” the city became widely known as the “World’s Egg Basket.”

Former site of the Petaluma Fruit Packing Company, 2026 (photo John Sheehy)

A version of this story was published in the Petaluma Argus-Courier, March 20, 2026.

******

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “Editorial Dashes,” Petaluma Courier, February 15, 1882; “D.E. Ashby, Old Settler of Palo Alto, Passes,” The Peninsula Times Tribune, November 22, 1923.

[2] James Gerber, “The Gold Rush Origins of California’s Wheat Economy,” http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S1405-22532010000200002; Santa Rosa: A Nineteenth Century Town (Historia, Ltd., 1985), p. 102; “Sonoma County,” Petaluma Courier, December 10, 1890; U.S. Census: Petaluma’s population essentially plateaued from 2,868 in 1870 to only 3,871 by 1900, while Santa Rosa’s grew from 2,989 in 1870 to 6,673 by 1900. Petaluma’s population increased to 5,880 in 1910, thanks largely to the egg boom.

[3] “Golden Gate Fruit Packing Company,” San Jose Mercury News, August 2, 1877; “Obituary,” Los Gatos Mail, April 25, 1901; “A New Industry,” San Jose Mercury News, April 22, 1873; “Fruit Canning and Drying,” Petaluma Argus, April 25, 1873; “The Cannery,” Napa County Register, April 9, 1886;

“Cannery Life in the Santa Clara Valley,” History San Jose.com, https://historysanjose.org/plan-your-visit/exhibits-activities/online-exhibits/cannery-life-del-monte-in-the-santa-clara-valley/

[4] “Santa Barbara Fruit Cannery, “ Santa Barbara Morning Press, April 1, 1880; “The City,” Santa Barbara Morning Press, March 11, 1881; “Important Industry,” Los Angeles Daily Commercial, June 23, 1881.

[5] Sanuel Cassiday, “J.W. Cassidy,” History of Sonoma County (Lewis & Co., 1889), pps. 465-466; “Strawberries,” Sonoma County Journal, May 27, 1859; “About Cherries,” Petaluma Argus, May 29, 1874. Note: W. H. Pepper of the Liberty Nursery was the largest cherry producer; “Large Cherry Orchard,” Petaluma Argus, June 7, 1884; “Mrs. Cassidy Answers Call,” Petaluma Courier, October 21, 1913.

[6] “An Important Invention,” Petaluma Argus, June 26, 1874; “Cassidy Fruit Dryer,” Petaluma Argus, September 18, 1874; “The Fire Fiend,” Petaluma Argus, September 25, 1874.

[7] “Novato Hangs on to Rich History,” Marin Independent Journal, September 19, 2006.

[8] History of Marin County (Alley, Bowen & Co., 1880), p. 439-440; “A California Ranch,” California Farmer and Journal of Useful Sciences, May 2, 1878; “Novato Hangs on to Rich History,” Marin Independent Journal, September 19, 2006.

[9] “The Cannery,” Petaluma Argus, March 3, 1883; “Our Fruit Cannery,” Petaluma Courier, March 14, 1883; “Questions Answered,” Petaluma Argus, March 31, 1883.

[10] “Fine Canned Fruit,” Petaluma Argus, June 8, 1883; “Flattering Prospects of the New Enterprise at Petaluma,” San Francisco Call Bulletin, June 15, 1883.

[11] “Flattering Prospects of the New Enterprise at Petaluma,” San Francisco Call Bulletin, June 15, 1883.

[12] “Flattering Prospects of the New Enterprise at Petaluma,” San Francisco Call Bulletin, June 15, 1883.

[13] “Courierlets,” Petaluma Courier, August 8, 1883; “The Cannery,” Petaluma Argus, May 17, 1884; “The Cannery,” Napa County Register, April 9, 1886; “How Canning of California Products has Grown into a World-famous Industry,” San Francisco Chronicle, January 1, 1904; “D.E. Ashby, Old Settler of Palo Alto, Passes,” Peninsula Times Tribune, November 22, 1923.

[14] “Ranch Brings Cool Million,” Petaluma Argus, December 22, 1905.

[15] “Copartnership Notice,” Petaluma Courier, October 27, 1886. Note: Field & Stone, a fruit broker in San Francisco, was also partners in the new Delong, Ashby & Co.

[16] “The Petaluma Cannery,” Petaluma Courier, August 10, 1887; “Local Brevities,” Sonoma Democrat, July 31, 1888; “Petaluma Industries,” Petaluma Courier, July 10, 1889.

[17] Note: Joseph Black appears to have opened Sonoma County’s first factory-scale cannery in Santa Rosa in 1881 with 29 employees. He rebuilt it in 1887, after the building burnedr down (“Santa Rosa Items,” Cloverdale Reveille, August 20, 1881; “Santa Rosa Items,” Cloverdale Reveille, September 10, 1881; “About Tramps,” Petaluma Courier, September 22, 1886; “The New Cannery,” Sonoma Democrat, June 4, 1887). In 1888, J.H. Hunt started a cannery in Sebastopol (“Canning and Drying,” Sonoma Democrat, June 29, 1889), and T.S. Merchant started the Magnolia Cannery in Healdsburg (“Magnolia Cannery,” Healdsburg Enterprise, April 12, 1888). The Hunt Brothers Cannery opened in Sebastopol in 1889, and in 1890 expanded to plants in Santa Rosa and Carquinez to become the largest in the North Bay (“Local Brevities,” Santa Rosa Press Democrat, July 21, 1889; “Cannery at Santa Rosa,” San Francisco Chronicle, April 11, 1890).

[18] “The Silk Mill,” Petaluma Courier, December 8, 1891; “Carlson-Currier Company,” Petaluma Courier, October 19, 1892;

[19] “Petaluma: Its Advantages, Industries, and Resources,” Petaluma Courier, October 19, 1892; “Nearly Eight Hundred,” Petaluma Courier, March 1, 1893.

[20] “Wanted: Work,” Petaluma Courier, August 11, 1893.

[21] “Ranch Brings Cool Million,” Petaluma Argus, December 22, 1905; “F.C. DeLong,” Petaluma Courier, June 28, 1910.

[22] “Ranch Brings Cool Million,” Petaluma Argus, December 22, 1905; “Ancient History Reviewed,” Petaluma Courier, February 7, 1913.

[23] “Wanted: Work,” Petaluma Courier, August 11, 1893; “The Rancho Novato,” Petaluma Courier, May 16, 1894.

[24] “Preparing for Business,” Petaluma Courier, May 12, 1906.

[25] “Big Deal is Now Pending,” Petaluma Argus, May 12, 1910; “Title Now Cleared on Heynemann Lot,” Petaluma Courier, May 19, 1911; “Heynemann Co. to Close Local Factory,” Petaluma Courier, June 18, 1913; “Fire Burns the McNear Warehouse,” Petaluma Courier, January 19, 1915; “Grass Fire is Cause of Still Alarm,” Petaluma Courier, October 30, 1915.

[26] “Ranch Brings Cool Million,” Petaluma Argus, December 22, 1905; “Ancient History Reviewed,” Petaluma Courier, February 7, 1913.

[26a] “Cherry Valley,” Petaluma Courier, May 4, 1887; Note: what was called Cherry Valley by 1887 extended from the west end of Howard Street at the city limits of Petaluma, northwest to the west end of the Cypress Hill Cemetery, comprising almost 100 acres.

[27] “Damages for Infringement,” San Francisco Chronicle, December 30, 1891; Court Notes,” San Francisco Chronicle, March 18, 1892; “A Surprised Inventor,” San Francisco Examiner, August 31, 1893; Cassidy Won His Suit,” San Francisco Call Bulletin, October 30, 1894; Note: The Hunt Brothers appealed the decision, and Cassidy won the appeal.

[28] “Sonoma County Fruit Company,” Petaluma Courier, May 6, 1891; Cassidy sold his orchard in 1899 to J.B. Dickson, and died in Petaluma in 1903 (“A New Firm,” Petaluma Argus, October 5, 1899; “Pioneer Orchardist Dies,” San Francisco Examiner, August 9, 1903).

[29] “Who Really Invented the Petaluma Incubator,” PetalumaHisstorian.com, https://petalumahistorian.com/who-really-invented-the-petaluma-incubator.